GAMES: GameSpot GameFAQs MOVIES: Metacritic Movietome Comic-Con
Monday, Sep 7, 2009

As we all know, this week will bring the return of Supernatural! I'd say that totally deserves a blog

I've spent the last month rewatching the entire series. Started Aug 3rd and finished Sept 5th. Saw the two first seasons in 10 days, then chilled after that. Started with worrying weither I was even gonna make it, but ended up being done a week before I had to, and I could have been done sooner. I think I did good.

Figured I'd do a little review.

All in all, what I'm left with.. I dunno, I'm a little underwhelmed, but not really.. I don't like to say it but in a way I feel like Kripke, without really doing it, has sort of ruined his own show. What I mean is, it has been building up, and building up, and building up.. Which of course is amazing, but looking back, albeit the quality of the show is just the same, meaning it is still an utterly amazing show, but the impact it leaves, is getting smaller.. I like to use the finale of S2 as an exsample, coz I remember I was all over the top excited about it, and it was so awesome, and we thought we were really starting to see some of Kripke's plan, and we knew all about YED... But, turns out, we were wrong! Which isn't necessarily a bad thing. It just lowers the impact. Of course, S2 is a long time ago, lots of things have happened, we know so much more now. But that's not ethe issue. Not really. It's not what has happened, it's how it's happened... Uhm, I feel this got messy, makes more sense in my head... Further on this tho, and I know I said this upto several times during last season, everything has gotten too big now! It is too heavy! It has taken away the impact from previous serasons, but has taken on too big an impact so it's hard to comprehend it all.. And even bigger it gets...? But ah, bring it on!

Ok, on to some of my thought that I have collected during my watch, and that I still remember right now

I just can't get over John! Everytime when I rewatch, it builds up all thru S1, more or less stays with throughout S2, then sort of fades away a bit, gets a boost every now and again, especially early in S4, and still, now.. I'm left here, wondering; Just how much did John know!?!?! Supposedly, he knew. But knew what? Did he know the full extent of YED's plan? Did he know only to the end of S2, or did he know beyond that? Did he know all the way thru to the end of S4? Is it even bigger? He did not break for 10 months/100 years, which might indicate he did know. But did he really know the whole, full plan? Everything? All the way down to the Apocalypse? Why did he keep it to himself? Did he know Sam was gonna (be tempted to) go down the rute he did end up going down? The "Save him or kill him" idicates he might of. But how? And did he know that Dean might start it by going in after he got out? I could go on, but you know where this is all going. How much did John know, and how did he know it??!? Also, have to say, John, IMO, has to be the best hunter! (That we have been introduced to anyway. I know there are others that we have not heard of, and there are those we have breifly heard of, and those we have met briefly, and there are those we know...and, by what I can tell (and if John really did know...which I'm leaning towards he did), he has got to have been the best!)

Another thing that I can't let go, but I think we're supposed to get an answer to, Croatoan!??! I hope so... but I'm not sure (No spoilers please! Uhm..ok, if you know anything, you can confirm or disconfirm it, but no more info! )

One more thing: Do we know why the CRD said she could get in trouble for dealing with Dean?

The best episode: What Is and What Should Never Be! Such a fantastic episode! It is just about perfect! Honestly, it's the best episode I have ever seen, of any show, ever! It is so amazing! I love it so much!!! I mean, the story, the writing, the acting, the directing, the editing, everything! It is all so incredible! It doesn't hurt that it is kind of special with the fact that it was the first ep Kripke ever directed. But that's just a bonus. And he did a great job! And, I mean, the acting! Jensen, the guy who always deliveres, outdoes even himself on this ep! I just can't get over it! Why did he not get an award for that ep!?! And the editing/cutting! It is so amazing! Seeing Dean's reflection in the pictures/the computer. And when he sees/remembers from the warehouse. (The girl and the people hanging) The first time he saw those people hanging in his closet, I thought that they were actually there, hanging in his closet! I thought like, "what, the dude thinks he's normal, got a normal life, and then the poor kid goes off to find people hanging in his closet!?!" But then the girl was there, but then she was gone, and so were the people... Man... Aw, Dean continually broke my heart! Seriously, the first time I saw it, I cried straight thru the whole ep! From the first scene with Mary, and throughout. And occationaly I lughed. And then I cried again, then lauged, etc..such an emotional rollercoster for me this ep!I love it! I mean, the jokes were so great, and maybe, because it was so emotional, those tiny moments of humor just became all the more pleasant. But come on! "I can't believe were even related." ... "You're still my brother." "B1tch." "What are you calling me a B1tch for?!" "You're supposed to say jerk...nevermind." And the end!!! Dude is actually apologizing to his imaginationary family (and he knows they're just his imagination) for not staying! And he's willing to kill himself for something he's 90% sure of! He had everything he ever wanted, but was 90% sure it wasn't really, so he killed himself! Or, he almost did, then they confirmed it was imaginary and tried to convince him to stay, and then he apologized and... And he "wanted to stay so bad"!!! Obviously, I'm glad he didn't stay, and I appreciate all the crap that happens to them, coz the show wouldn't be what it is without it (the core of the show is to torture the main characters) but it breaks my heart every time! And there's the lawnmower scene!!! And the graveyard scene! (had to be mentioned..)And I could go on, but I'll stop myself there I LOVE THIS EPISODE!!!!!!!

The ep I wish I loved: The Rapture. I want to love this ep, but I can't. It just..it could have been so much more...Or maybe it was enough, but it could have been done so much better! I mean, it's a great story, and Misha is....well, he's Misha! But the writing just... Especially some of the dialogues.. and some of the monologues aswell.. and just general conversations.. Some is good, but some just doesn't sit right with me. Also.. the guests could have been better. Actually, the girl, Claire (Not bothered to go find their names) she did a good job. She was just sort of there as Claire, she was an important, but not a very big character, but I felt she did Castiel justice. And that is not at all a bad accomplishment by a young girl Amelia on the other hand.. Ok, to be fair, she was abit victimised by the bad writing I mentioned. It was especially the (first) dialogue(s) between her and Jimmy that felt odd to me (After he returned. Present time, not past.). I blame both the acting and the writing there.. The one when he is about to leave again, and she is sitting in the car, he's kneeling down outside the car, that one was nice tho So yes, all in all a good episode, but it could have been done better. And I wish it had been done better. I can't fully enjoy it when I know it could have been so much better! And very easily so! And I wish Castiel/Jimmy/Misha could have gotten a really fabulous episode! Considered how big and important Cas/Misha is, both to the show and the fans, he should have gotten a truely fabuous ep! He had a great story, but, unfortunately, they just weren't able to execute it..

That's all I can bring to mind right now...

How excited are we tho!?!?!?!!? I cannot wait!!!!! It's gonna be gooooooood!!!! I am fairly spoiler free, but the little bits and pieces that I know.. It's goona be gooood!!! So excited!!

(Please go wild on the comments, but no spoilers )

Posted by supering, 11:55am
16 Comments | Post a Comment

Comments

Page 1 
« prev  |  next »
FIRSTNESS!!
Posted Sep 7, 2009 12:22 pm PT
Grrr... TV.com is being stupid and won't let me post my comment. I'll PM you it.
Posted Sep 7, 2009 12:40 pm PT
PM'd you back!
And congratz on your regular firstness
Posted Sep 7, 2009 1:23 pm PT
Isnt progression a good thing, isnt that what fans want to see? If the show continues delivering events on the same scale as it did in previous season wouldnt we get disappointed? I would! However, i do know what yur getting at. After the devil.... what next? He is the original badass so after the brothers resolve the issue of him being set free what can possibly top that? Doesnt the show have to end? Eh, im not gonna ramble in someone elses blog . I wont get into fully but what we learned in the episode "In the Beginning" seems to be soooo clear to me but after it aired in the forum i was shocked that so many people had different ideas about how things went down. I guess interpretation is a good thing cus its sparks conversation and debate about the show. Later .
Posted Sep 7, 2009 3:49 pm PT
Well, of course, progression! I love that part, they don't dwell on anything (for too long) Sam and Dean have both evolved so much since the pilot, and the story keeps changing.. It is awesome. But too awesome? I love that it has progression, but it is making the prevous seasons/episodes loose their impact.. "It's not what has happened, it's how it's happened..." I mean.. Ahw, I can't really explain it I guess... It is just too much, too heavy, but still so incredebly good, and yes, if there was no progression, then we'd be bored, and I'm just complaining but really.... Ah I'll just shut up coz I don't feel like I get anywhere
Go on, just ramble on all you want! But yea, what does come next? I wonder if Kripke is going on about this slight possibility of S6 to make us think it could happen, to hide that he's gonna end the world and kill everyone.... :/
Oh yes, what would a discussion forum be without people's various interpretations
Posted Sep 8, 2009 1:57 am PT
Well, of course, progression! I love that part, they don't dwell on anything (for too long) Sam and Dean have both evolved so much since the pilot, and the story keeps changing.. It is awesome. But too awesome? I love that it has progression, but it is making the prevous seasons/episodes loose their impact.. "It's not what has happened, it's how it's happened..." I mean.. Ahw, I can't really explain it I guess... It is just too much, too heavy, but still so incredebly good, and yes, if there was no progression, then we'd be bored, and I'm just complaining but really.... Ah I'll just shut up coz I don't feel like I get anywhere
Go on, just ramble on all you want! But yea, what does come next? I wonder if Kripke is going on about this slight possibility of S6 to make us think it could happen, to hide that he's gonna end the world and kill everyone.... :/
Oh yes, what would a discussion forum be without people's various interpretations
Posted Sep 8, 2009 1:58 am PT
Maybe it's because I'm a sucker for the whole godd vs evil/God vs the Devil theme in anything, I loved S4 and am really excited for S5. But I can understand your feelings cause I too have seen a kind of disconnect with previous seasons and archs. But anywho. 2 days, 9 hours and 4 minutes to go! *squee*
Posted Sep 8, 2009 6:56 am PT
Well, yea, sure I liked S4, I really did, it was amazing! Much better than S3! I mean, come on, they just couldn't go wrong with the introduction of Cas!!
But yes...
And I am SOOOOO Excited for Season 5!!!! So freakin excited!!!!
Posted Sep 8, 2009 7:41 am PT
[This message was deleted at the request of the original poster]
Posted Sep 9, 2009 9:34 am PT
[This message was deleted at the request of the original poster]
Posted Sep 9, 2009 9:49 am PT
Nice to meet you! Aw, SPN anticipation, I am in. I wish I would have managed a rewatch as well. I get your point on John, I wondered that as well... I really hope they can tie the knots for us and answer that question a little. I also get that it's much bigger than in season 2 (which I positively loved). Still, keeping the tone of season 2 without new bigger mysteries wouldn't have worked either... Me, I really liked season3 And it's good to be critical. In fact I noticed some less good writing as well, lately. But, like for you, that doesn't take away from the fact that I am excited for SPN every week as much as hardly for any other show. And that episode you mention rocked! Go season 5!
Posted Sep 9, 2009 9:49 am PT
Supes...almost missed your blog review! It's way to late and I have to get up in 5 hours for work **cry** so I'll be back tomorrow! And since it's after midnight here...Happy SPN Thursday!!!
Posted Sep 9, 2009 9:35 pm PT
Ela! Hello!
I love to rewatch
Aw John.. love him..so many unanswered questions.../:
Yea, they had to go further and add more than what they had in S2, but still, it feels too big sometimes.
Sure, I liked S3, but all in all it's the worst season
Right, they give us so much of top quality, that we just gotta look past the occational not-quite-top-notch eps/moments. You know, because the show is so good, and they keep such a constant high level, we have come to exspect nothing but greatness from every ep, so when an ep happens to be only good, then it is bad in SN standards and we start complaining. We are just spoilt really
IT IS THURSDAY!!!!!!! SEASON 5 !!!!!!!!!!!!!!
Posted Sep 10, 2009 3:00 am PT
Puma! Better late than never, right
Have fun at work!
HAPPY SUPERNATURAL THURSDAY!!!
Posted Sep 10, 2009 3:01 am PT
I have been real busy and didn't have time to look up the posts - better late than never, as it has already been said! I completely understand what you mean by The Rapture! I loved the episode, but something was not quite right about. I could not put my finger on it! And, yes, so many unanswered questions, so many more to come?? Loved the season premiere! It maybe could have been a bit stronger, but great nonetheless!
Posted Sep 12, 2009 2:11 am PT
Moni!
Aw..The Rapture... Questions! Answers! More questions!
Yep, premiere was good! I'm with you, it could have been stronger, but it was great. I'm sure there will be lots of strong eps later in the season.
Posted Sep 12, 2009 6:08 am PT
Page 1 
« prev  |  next »
  • supering
  • Level: 1 (0%)
  • Rank: Mogwai
  • Forum Posts: 950
  • Messages Read: 0


advertisement

Friends

My Friends