GAMES: GameSpot GameFAQs MOVIES: Metacritic Movietome Comic-Con
Tuesday, Oct 2, 2007

Each year when the new seasons start up, I get a crop of episode submissions for the guides, many of which do not meet TV.com criteria (which you can find at the forum post titled Criteria of Acceptance: Episode Submissions for NEW Unaired Shows...). All episode submissions must meet those guidelines -- and these are rules that need to be followed by not only the average submitter, but also editors and trusted users.

What are the guidelines? Simply this -- any submissions for new, unaired episodes must provide a source link (in the comments field), and must have two of the following:
- Episode Title
- Episode Airdate
- Episode Summary

Which means that if it doesn't have two of the three, it shouldn't be there. And UNKNOWN, TBA, etc, are not valid episode titles. I've never seen a situation where the summary and airdate are known but not a title -- a far more likely scenario is that the airdate and title are known but not the summary, or the airdate and summary are known but not the title.

And any submissions for any episode that hasn't aired yet (according to the TV.com guidelines in that link, which are provided by the administration) must be accompanied by a link. And the IMDb is not a valid source.

Thank you very much.

Comments

Page 1 
« prev  |  next »
How frustrating! That's why I only edit dead shows.
Posted Oct 2, 2007 8:39 am PT
Scary thing is when those get raided too. I've got two series that had spinoffs -- every few months someone tries to take the episodes from the spinoffs and incorporate them into the original. If the show has been off the air over ten years, odds are there are no 'new' eppies to add.
Posted Oct 2, 2007 9:35 am PT
TBA / Unknown is not needed in the Episode Summary anymore; they can just be left blank.

I do have one case where the official titles in a season are indeed unknown but those are rare exceptions to the case where most titles are presented in some form in a listing.
Posted Oct 2, 2007 2:38 pm PT
I've no objection to a blank episode, as long as it has a title and a verified airdate. (I admit, I prefer a bit of info, but I'll take nothing as long as the rest of the criteria is met.)
Posted Oct 3, 2007 12:00 am PT
I think TBA/Unknown ought to be considered gaming now for both the summary and recap sections. Including it bumps the point value for the submission, and if the same person returns with a summary after broadcast or a press release, then it's double dipping.
Posted Oct 3, 2007 12:16 am PT
Good to know the rule since I give up trying to find out stuff in the Forums section. It's like a maze to find answers to your stuff in there.
Posted Oct 5, 2007 9:37 am PT
Page 1 
« prev  |  next »
  • khaki_dojo
  • Level: 2 (60%)
  • Rank: 2 Dollars
  • Forum Posts: 338
  • Messages Read: 127


Friends

My Friends