GAMES: GameSpot GameFAQs MOVIES: Metacritic Movietome Comic-Con
Friday, Sep 25, 2009

I collect games as most of you know, and I'm also a horror and sci-fi movie buff who buys movies and seasons of TV series on disc at times. I was a fairly early adopter of the HD-DVD drive for the 360 and after the hi-def format war was over, I was really happy to find a combination Blu-Ray and HD-DVD player so that I could keep my existing hi-def library and build on it. I also own a PS3, which means that I have two devices for each format (HD-DVD and Blu-Ray) in my house. I didn't mind terribly the long start-up and load times, even though DVD had none, since the picture was spectacular. I was perturbed at the four firmware upgrades on the combo player of which DVD had none. I don't view a video playback device as more firmware-needy than a toaster. It may be naive, but I think that once the codec is set, that's it. It would be like requiring a software upgrade to toast wheat bread and bagels in addition to the white bread and English muffins that the toaster could handle out of the box. I was even starting to replace some things I own on DVD with hi-def versions.

Fast forward to a few weeks ago, and my combo player and PS3 have both stopped reading anything above a DVD. I'm more than perturbed now and the format upgrading is over. I'm in the process of getting both devices repaired, but my confidence in Blu-Ray as the disc format of the future is substantially reduced.

Tonight I bought Season Two of Terminator on DVD, even though I own Season One on Blu-Ray. I'll miss the higher video quality, but at least I'll be able to watch the damn show.

Posted by gmsnpr, 8:31pm
4 Comments | Post a Comment

Comments

Page 1 
« prev  |  next »
I gotta be honest, neither HD-DVD nor Blu-Ray impressed me enough to warrant an upgrade. I don't feel that the difference is so substantial to be worth the investment in either. projection to VHS to DVD are all substantial upgrades, but going from DVD to blu-ray/HD-DVD just isnt within the expectations I have for a new format. They are not any more convenient, nor are they cheaper or smaller. The video quality is of course greater, but so much greater to be worth the price tag. I'm sorry you've been having so many issues though, because while I may not feel like upgrading, you did, and it hasnt worked out.
Posted Sep 26, 2009 1:41 pm PT
I agree with you whole-heartedly on this. At first blush, firmware updates seem like a great thing; hey, you can make my device better? Wonderful. Of course, as you mentioned, updating stuff in this manner alows for the chance to break the stuff as well. Not only that, but I'm worried it might introduce firmware requirements on particular media. Imagine buying a movie that you can't watch because your player isn't up to date. Heck, imagine PC game style required/recommended settings appearing on movie packaging. Sickening. And I doubt they will be able to supply firmware updates on the media itself (a la PSP and UMD discs) because there are multiple blu-ray players made by multiple companies. I don't like to think of myself as a pessimist, but this post certainly sounds that way. I just like stuff I buy to work.
Posted Oct 1, 2009 7:33 pm PT
Just out of curiosity, is this that PS3 you bought a little while back that was having troulbe with Blu-Rays to start with, or is this one you purchased new?
Posted Oct 1, 2009 7:35 pm PT
It was the first PS3. It didn't really break on my watch, but it's still a Blu-ray device in my possession that will no longer work properly. The firmware thing is precisely what you've described. Usually it's based on incompatibility with new releases, which causes the userbase to go ballistic and the service team to write new firmware under duress. Firmware updates are almost never preventive in nature--they're to correct specific, identified bugs, like not being able to play Tropic Thunder, for example (or to un-brick Wiis).
Posted Oct 1, 2009 7:44 pm PT
Page 1 
« prev  |  next »
  • gmsnpr
  • Level: 1 (0%)
  • Rank: Mogwai
  • Forum Posts: 289
  • Messages Read: 0


advertisement
Click Here

Friends

My Friends