GAMES: GameSpot GameFAQs MOVIES: Metacritic Movietome Comic-Con
Sunday, Nov 23, 2008
So, this Sunday, 23rd November 2008, marks the 45th anniversary of Doctor Who. Hooray! On this day, back in 1963, William Hartnell first stepped out of the TARDIS, and I bet he didn't come close to imagining the sheer scale of the British institution that he was starting.

Unfortunately for me, I didn't have the opportunity to immerse myself in the Whoniverse for the next 25-odd years ( ), and even then I somehow never got around to watching until I was in my late teens. Of course I knew all about the Daleks, for one through having watched that film – the name evades me – with the Robomen, a mine shaft and a large bomb set to detonate in so many rels, that ITV seemed only too keen to repeat a few times each year. It was good, but not amazing, and in all honesty it somewhat put me off hunting down the old episodes.

However, in 2003 the BBC announced that they planned to create a new series, and, even having let 'Classic Who' slide past me, I was genuinely excited! The 26th March 2005 came, and there we were, plunged right into the episode Rose (I still remember Graham Norton's less-than-dulcet tones intruding for the first few moments… grr…), and you know what? It was fantastic!

Having the honour of being editor for 'Nu Who', as it's sometimes affectionately known, I'm going to zoom through the highs and lows of this wonderful programme, in only the shallow, shallow detail that I have time for.

The Eccleston-Piper Era
I'm a strong believer that the Ninth Doctor is seriously underrated. Yes, David Tennant is (was ) truly amazing, but credit where credit's due, it was Christopher Eccleston that resuscitated Doctor Who, and made 'Nu Who' the success it is today. He was a dark and fairly mysterious Doctor, but I think that was a good thing.

Re-watching the series now (if you haven't watched any of series one since 2005, seriously, get a copy and re-watch ASAP), it's amazing to see just how good it was. Take The Empty Child and The Doctor Dances, for example. Such an incredibly clever plot, centring around Captain Jack, a Chula 'war ship', nanogenes, a truly loveable young lady called Nancy and her unfortunate 'brother' Jamie. This two-parter was a masterpiece, from our future chief Who writer Steven Moffat (oh yes, the future looks bright). We finished this series with Bad Wolf and The Parting of the Ways - a strong pair of episodes, that brought the series to a good close.

The Tennant-Piper Era
The Christmas Invasion. Now that was an interesting episode. Not the Sycorax side of the plot, which for me wasn't actually all that interesting, but Rose's reaction to the Tenth Doctor. Once she had got to grips with the new face, and we had waited another four or so months, we were introduced to New Earth, our first alien, (or not), planet. Using comedy, that fairly quickly shook off the old feel to the series, but then change is good.

The highlights of series two for me were definitely The Impossible Planet and The Satan Pit, which thinking about it was pretty much a return to the darker form of writing. Toby's transformation into The Beast was just terrifying, but again, the plot here was excellent. Skipping hastily past Love & Monsters, the series ended with what, in my eyes, is the best finale yet: Army of Ghosts and Doomsday. No normal person watched those final scenes without tears in their eyes.

The Tennant-Agyeman Era
A new series, a new companion. Martha was good. Not as good as either Rose or Donna, but definitely good. Yes, there were a couple of flops in this series: The Lazarus Experiment, 42, Last of the Time Lords… alright, this wasn't the best series to date. Still, we had wonders such as Blink (again, by good old Moffat), and who can forget Utopia? Uninteresting plot as a whole, but the main sub-plot, i.e. that of Dr. Yana, was fascinating.

The Tennant-Tate Era
Heh, Tennant-Tate, scarily similar to Doctor-Donna… After the slight dip in greatness that was series three, series four was right back on the mark. Pre-series, the amount of time I had to spend keeping an eye on anti-Tate messages in the forum was immense, and yet by the end, Donna was considered by many as the best companion yet, even surpassing Rose. It seems fairly clear that the most common reason for this is her lack of besotted-ness for the Doctor: a good call. Silence in the Library and Forest of the Dead were my favourites here (oh look, another Moffat pair…), but I'm not in the majority with that one.

Change
It's funny how people dislike change. Think about it: David Tennant is considered by so very many to be the best Doctor this show has ever had, but what happened just after Parting of the Ways, when we learnt of Christopher Eccleston's departure? There was an outcry, people were saying that he was their Doctor, and were genuinely upset about him leaving (I know I was). However, all was forgotten when Tennant began. Same was true with Rose to Martha, Martha to Donna, and who knows, perhaps the Tenth Doctor to the Eleventh. It is definitely sad that David Tennant is leaving, but not before he's given us three series worth of great fun.

Old and New
Finally, I leave you with these last few thoughts (not long to go, assuming you haven't already whizzed past me onto one of the other contributor's blog ). The revived Doctor Who is special for many, many reasons, but I think one of the most profound is the sheer demographic section that it appeals to. It appeals to children, teenagers and adults, it appeals to old fans and new viewers, it appeals to sci-fi junkies and those less interested in this finer genre in life.

How do I know this? After each and every episode, I come back to my computer and find my moderation queue full to bursting with notes, quotes, trivia points and allusions from a tonne of different contributors. Most I don't know, but of those I do, I know that are adults who have been interested in Who since before the dinosaurs took over this world (well, seems that long ago anyway ), there are teens who have seen more Who than me, and there are also many users who have seen very little, but still enjoy it to the extent that they feel compelled to contribute here on TV.com. In many ways, it's magical.

Doctor Who has survived very well for 45 years – here's to the next 45 years

Islander

NB: Be sure to check out TheOldBill's tribute as well!
Category: TV
Posted by _Islander_, 5:56am
36 Comments | Post a Comment

Comments

Page 1 
« prev  |  next »
A very fitting tribute to an absolutely cracking show. I must thank you for your patience in wading through the vast amount of submissions I put in per episode. I know it can't be easy being an editor of such a popular show. So many thanks to you!
Posted Nov 23, 2008 10:24 am PT
Excellent blog and a nice sum up of everything about the series. I was actually watching The Doctor's Daughter and The Five Doctors tonight. Check out my Season 4 review blog.
Posted Nov 23, 2008 3:19 pm PT
Nu Who? Love it! Those of us who grew up with the original show still cannot quite believe that it's back, better than ever. Saturday evenings are fun again!
Posted Nov 24, 2008 2:23 pm PT
I'm afraid I've never seen Doctor Who, but congrats on bringing the show this far! We'll have to really blow it out for the 50th Anniversary!
Posted Nov 24, 2008 4:32 pm PT
My friend is a Doctor Who fan, although here in America it's not even that popular, if it's popular at all here... i didn't even know about it until this year when my friend showed me it... lol... it's good though, pretty good... =]
Posted Nov 24, 2008 4:49 pm PT
Excellent blog!
Posted Nov 24, 2008 4:50 pm PT
Oh my gosh, I love this. This is a great sum up of the new Doctor Who.
Posted Nov 24, 2008 5:08 pm PT
Thank you for such an excellent post.
Posted Nov 24, 2008 5:35 pm PT
I too discovered Doctor Who in my late teens, two years ago haha. I had always written it off because it was a show my mother grew up with and loved but a good friend of mine shoved me in front of a tv and made me watch the Nu Who series and in the first five minutes I was completely in love. You hit all the right points with me in that summary. I'm sad to see David Tennant go but I'm completely stoked for the future of the show. In short (too late), great blog and thanks for all you do.
Posted Nov 24, 2008 5:35 pm PT
Good tribute. I still miss Ecclestone and now it seems I'm dooemd to miss Tennant as well.
Posted Nov 24, 2008 5:39 pm PT
here here islander! well done and i agree bring on another 35 years of doctor who!! (p.s when did David Tennant say his run as the doctor was done????!!!!! omg!!! no body told me!!!!!!!!)
Posted Nov 24, 2008 5:46 pm PT
Nice tribute to Doctor Who.
Posted Nov 24, 2008 6:22 pm PT
Wonderful Blog. Really captures the essence of the new Doctor Who. I had vague memories of the show as a child circa Tom Baker (the fourth and second best Doctor, after Tennant of course, very sad that he has to go). But I have faith Who will continue its greatness post-Tennant.

I got into the new series from the start and have been hooked ever since, then went back and started watching the old series. Even watched Shada with the Eighth doctor. All the best on your work Islander and here's to another 45 years. I'm outta here. Cue TARDIS sound effect
Posted Nov 24, 2008 7:16 pm PT
Thanks for giving us a special place to celebrate. Nice job.
Posted Nov 24, 2008 7:16 pm PT
The Eccleston-Piper Era--its just my favorite one mainly because its the one that introduce to me to the WhoUniverse
Posted Nov 24, 2008 8:06 pm PT
Blink --Just Amazing
Posted Nov 24, 2008 8:12 pm PT
I saw this show for the first time on scifi channel when it premiered, I didn't know anything about it and went in hoping to catch something to kill an hour, it was the best hour I spent in a long time and I'm glad I took the time.
Posted Nov 24, 2008 9:00 pm PT
Nice summary! Going to struggle without a proper series of Who next year ;(
Posted Nov 24, 2008 9:28 pm PT
I'm was sad when I found out that David Tennant was leaving, I nearly cried. He was amazing (as was Christopher Eccleston) and my mother and I will miss seeing him as The Doctor. I thought this was a beautifully written tribute to one of my favorite shows.
Posted Nov 24, 2008 9:45 pm PT
What a fitting tribute to the show. You've summed the Nu Who up perfectly (I'm so going to call it that from now on!). Well done for bringing the show this far. Bring on more Doctor Who
Posted Nov 25, 2008 1:15 am PT
I still have the first episode on vhs, all tom baker series and most of Jon Pertwee.
Posted Nov 25, 2008 4:30 am PT
But of course the adults have been watching it since before the Dinosaurs took over the Earth, but of course any good Who fan knows that was only 34 years ago.
Posted Nov 25, 2008 4:38 am PT
awsome blog i am a huge DW fan and it is a fitting tribute. i also think that the tennent-freema era could have been much better than it was but it was still good
Posted Nov 25, 2008 4:40 am PT
Thanks for the great blog! An excellent summation, and a place to celebrate this auspicious milestone. Who could ask for anything more?
Posted Nov 25, 2008 6:18 am PT
Excellent blog. As a new Who lover it gave me so much info. Thanks!
Posted Nov 25, 2008 8:28 am PT
i love this show since 2005! chrisopher was a funny doctor & david was amazing i will miss him his series was awesome! i have only seen a few old doctor who eps! love rose & donna & martha was alot better in series 4! series 4 had an amazing if not sad ending because donna was great & i was sad when she had to forget! by xmas i will own all david t's dr hu series!! i can't believe i have to wait for 2010 to see a full series but whoever takes over as the doctor i will try to like coz who knows he maybe just as good! love the tribute can't believe how long it has been on lol!
Posted Nov 26, 2008 5:47 am PT
Thank you for this excellent blog. Congratulations are definitely in order.
Posted Nov 26, 2008 10:26 am PT
I love the summary of such a great show (that I'm just getting into).

A bit off topic, have you seen the Comic Relief (I think....) clip with Lauren Cooper (character played by Tate from The Catherine Tate Show) being taught by Tennant.

It's hilarious. Here's the link of it, if you'd like:
http://au.youtube.com/watch?v=WxB1gB6K-2A
Posted Dec 5, 2008 3:32 am PT
Great blog! Every bit was true And I have to say I was one of those who was worried about the character changes - but it all turned out well haha. This coming season will be very interesting
Posted Dec 5, 2008 8:26 pm PT
[This message was deleted at the request of a moderator or administrator]
Posted Dec 16, 2008 7:40 am PT
Pretty tribute, nice words. I'm actually in the middle on seasons one and four. I've seen all of 2 and 3 so maybe I am more biased towards Tennent, but from what I've seen of Eccleston off camera, he seems somewhat dull, IMO. That's really only why I don't like him as much.
Posted Dec 17, 2008 8:48 am PT
Wow this is a great introduction to those of us who've only been watching the Christopher Eccleston and David Tennant years. One of these days I'll have to try to catch up on the first 8 Doctor's since there is so much history (past, present and future that is) that us newbies don't know about! Here's hopefully to the 11th Doctor soon.
Posted Dec 20, 2008 1:16 pm PT
"Doctor Who" needs a short, sharp, shock, right up your father's TARDIS! How about the next Dr being a black woman? The "colonies" will have a black President, soon, so isn't it about time for both minorities to break the white, male Doctor stranglehold (there *are* women doctors, ya know; even women Timelords! Remember Romana? Freema ("Martha Jones") Agyeman would have been perfect, but that ship has sailed, unless, of course, the Doctor, in an angst-ridden fit, regenerates into MJ, as the first Romana did for Princess Astra. Given the planet's penchant for Japanimation, maybe an oriental woman? (one of these days, I've got to stop mainlining jelly babies!)
Posted Dec 20, 2008 7:33 pm PT
I worked on a lot of the early WHO'S 1966 onwards,,,Great fun to do ...See IMDB.......aITCH,
Posted Jan 15, 2009 1:13 pm PT
I worked on many episodes of Who in the old days....

Aitch,
Posted Jan 17, 2009 4:01 am PT
I saw the original Dr Who shows in the U.S. on PBS. I was fortunate to see every Dr. through the fifth. The new Dr Who stories are very good, and true to the originals. However, there were 26 episodes in the original series' year, and only 13 in the new. The average length of each actor's portrayal was 4.25 seasons. I remember that each time lord could regenerate only 12 times. It seems BBC is going through these last 4 VERY quickly.
Posted Jan 17, 2009 9:25 pm PT
Page 1 
« prev  |  next »
  • _Islander_
  • Level: 1 (26%)
  • Rank: Mogwai
  • Forum Posts: 138
  • Messages Read: 35


advertisement

Friends

My Friends