Wednesday, Jun 11, 2008
~Elven Lied~

Kind of short, I finished it in about a day. And by "finish" I mean it said the end, it obviously isn't over cuz they left so damn much unanswered and unresolved. I mean I don't mean to sound so harsh, but what the hell was resolved? The research lab is still up and going with AT LEAST 31 more little girls with horns being tortured in the name of science (unless some of them are already dead) and the diclonius dude who owned the lab and wants to kill off humanity is still alive. Not to mention we don't know who the girl standing at the gate of the hotel was and there's still some random chick who got infected out there. (the one Lucy infected while she was wandering about.)
Now I know that leaving a story open ended for interpretation is awesome sometimes (Shadow of the Colossus FTW) but there's a bit of a difference between open for interpretation and leaving loose ends. If I'm missing something and there is a couple of clues that lead to a possible answer to those things then please tell me them.
However, I know it's not quite over, there's always the manga. However, I'm worried about what if there's other differences. See, they left a bunch of loose ends, but what they DID end I really liked. I liked that Nana and Mayu were able to live peacefully (they deserved it) and I really like the whole thing with Kurama and his daughter Mariko (#35). Actually that probably was my favorite part, I gots teary at it.>.> And I accidentally caught a bit of the Wikipedia article and that's not how it turns out.
Plus another thing I liked about it was the **** That amount of explicit nudity and gore is often looked down upon but I think they pulled it off in a very artistic manner. I mean sure some of the nudity was just fanservice but most of it was just supposed to make you feel utter pity and had nothing to do with getting boners. (unless of course you're sick you sick sicko) And well, I guess I should judge a book by it's cover but...

Just looking at this I kind of get the feeling that I'm not going to have the same respect when they have lots of nudity.>.> I just can't take boobs that large seriously. In the show they didn't make it all about their boobs, they were just naked for some sad reason. (once again, minus the fanservice.)
So I don't know, the manga seams like a bad idea at first glance, but I just need more depth. There weren't any major twists that made me gasp, it didn't really end and I just didn't have much to think about when it ended. It just seamed like it had all the potential in the world and was just kind of shallow IMO. I think part of it is my fault though, I have a feeling I emotionally blocked it out. I watched it fully intending to be depressed for a week. And it delivered, I really should of cried, but I didn't. I don't know why, but it didn't hit me as hard as it should of.
The exception is Kurama though, (guy with glasses) it seams like everything around him delivered. The three saddest things were the whole situation with Nana in ep 2-5 (I think), the part when his wife came into the room bleeding all over the place begging him to let her kid (#35) live, and the last part with him and #35 which started out sad then turned out sweet and sad. Also the one thing I latter went "oh that's why" while thinking back on things was the reason why Lucy didn't kill him. Seriously, it's like all the best parts had something to do with him.
Meh, I feel kind of like this is a random rant. Main question, do you think the manga is worth it or will it kill what little I have with the show?
PS: Is this a common theme in animes or did I just get lucky? It starts with some guy finding a naked girl and bringing her home to find out that she has no intelligence about anything. Latter you find out she's actually something quite big that can cause a crap load of problems so some people are hunting her down. She also has a second personality that knows what's going on and is thought to be evil at some point. I've only seen two animes, Chobits and Elven Lied. That fits them both.

Kind of short, I finished it in about a day. And by "finish" I mean it said the end, it obviously isn't over cuz they left so damn much unanswered and unresolved. I mean I don't mean to sound so harsh, but what the hell was resolved? The research lab is still up and going with AT LEAST 31 more little girls with horns being tortured in the name of science (unless some of them are already dead) and the diclonius dude who owned the lab and wants to kill off humanity is still alive. Not to mention we don't know who the girl standing at the gate of the hotel was and there's still some random chick who got infected out there. (the one Lucy infected while she was wandering about.)
Now I know that leaving a story open ended for interpretation is awesome sometimes (Shadow of the Colossus FTW) but there's a bit of a difference between open for interpretation and leaving loose ends. If I'm missing something and there is a couple of clues that lead to a possible answer to those things then please tell me them.
However, I know it's not quite over, there's always the manga. However, I'm worried about what if there's other differences. See, they left a bunch of loose ends, but what they DID end I really liked. I liked that Nana and Mayu were able to live peacefully (they deserved it) and I really like the whole thing with Kurama and his daughter Mariko (#35). Actually that probably was my favorite part, I gots teary at it.>.> And I accidentally caught a bit of the Wikipedia article and that's not how it turns out.
Plus another thing I liked about it was the **** That amount of explicit nudity and gore is often looked down upon but I think they pulled it off in a very artistic manner. I mean sure some of the nudity was just fanservice but most of it was just supposed to make you feel utter pity and had nothing to do with getting boners. (unless of course you're sick you sick sicko) And well, I guess I should judge a book by it's cover but...

Just looking at this I kind of get the feeling that I'm not going to have the same respect when they have lots of nudity.>.> I just can't take boobs that large seriously. In the show they didn't make it all about their boobs, they were just naked for some sad reason. (once again, minus the fanservice.)
So I don't know, the manga seams like a bad idea at first glance, but I just need more depth. There weren't any major twists that made me gasp, it didn't really end and I just didn't have much to think about when it ended. It just seamed like it had all the potential in the world and was just kind of shallow IMO. I think part of it is my fault though, I have a feeling I emotionally blocked it out. I watched it fully intending to be depressed for a week. And it delivered, I really should of cried, but I didn't. I don't know why, but it didn't hit me as hard as it should of.
The exception is Kurama though, (guy with glasses) it seams like everything around him delivered. The three saddest things were the whole situation with Nana in ep 2-5 (I think), the part when his wife came into the room bleeding all over the place begging him to let her kid (#35) live, and the last part with him and #35 which started out sad then turned out sweet and sad. Also the one thing I latter went "oh that's why" while thinking back on things was the reason why Lucy didn't kill him. Seriously, it's like all the best parts had something to do with him.
Meh, I feel kind of like this is a random rant. Main question, do you think the manga is worth it or will it kill what little I have with the show?
PS: Is this a common theme in animes or did I just get lucky? It starts with some guy finding a naked girl and bringing her home to find out that she has no intelligence about anything. Latter you find out she's actually something quite big that can cause a crap load of problems so some people are hunting her down. She also has a second personality that knows what's going on and is thought to be evil at some point. I've only seen two animes, Chobits and Elven Lied. That fits them both.
Comments
Page
1
« prev
|
next »
Posted Jun 11, 2008 6:55 am PT
(Huh i was going to tell u it was Elfen not Elven but apparently its correct both ways) U got lucky with elven, this is a really good show i watched it like 3 times a few years ago, i remember going holy **** cant believe that happened
. But now i totally forgot most of it
, i remember a few key scenes thats it.
U should get used to animes ending in a major cliffhanger and also dont expect them to release anything else, unless u r willing to read the manga(which im not) most of the times u wont know what happened next, Berserk this show from the 90's (so good) i was so psyched about this it had 25 eps and still ended badly.
U can probably find more shows like these if u want, theres always like a theme with these shows. I cant think of any right now but i'll take a look at the good ol anime library and get back to u. What are u watching next, make sure is good b4 u watch it, i always go to ANN and see what are the top shows never lets me down.
U should get used to animes ending in a major cliffhanger and also dont expect them to release anything else, unless u r willing to read the manga(which im not) most of the times u wont know what happened next, Berserk this show from the 90's (so good) i was so psyched about this it had 25 eps and still ended badly.
U can probably find more shows like these if u want, theres always like a theme with these shows. I cant think of any right now but i'll take a look at the good ol anime library and get back to u. What are u watching next, make sure is good b4 u watch it, i always go to ANN and see what are the top shows never lets me down.
Posted Jun 11, 2008 9:53 am PT
Ack, I hate things that don't end.
My feeling are like the same as before I watched it. (intrigued but I don't really have anything to dig into.)
I'm not saying it was bad btw, it was pretty good. It just feels like it should of been more though. I don't know, maybe I had impossible expectations for it. I think I also knew most of what was coming thus the shock was dimmed. (and you kind of saw it all in the first few episodes.)
As for my next thing, the more I think about it the more I want to go to a manga. Either if it's Chobits or Elfen Lied (I'll call it right from now on
) I'm going to read one. I'll probably flip through Elfen Lied to check and see if it has the same style and if it does then pick it up.
But even before that, MGS4 is coming out so everything is going to be on hold.
Heck I still need to play MGS 1/2.
I'm not saying it was bad btw, it was pretty good. It just feels like it should of been more though. I don't know, maybe I had impossible expectations for it. I think I also knew most of what was coming thus the shock was dimmed. (and you kind of saw it all in the first few episodes.)
As for my next thing, the more I think about it the more I want to go to a manga. Either if it's Chobits or Elfen Lied (I'll call it right from now on
But even before that, MGS4 is coming out so everything is going to be on hold.
Posted Jun 11, 2008 12:09 pm PT
Laaaaaaaaaaaame if u don't finish those 2 games u wont understand the story, MGS3 is reaaaaaaaaaally important as well if u plan on getting anything of what they r saying in MGS4 u must play all 3 games(even portable ops if u can).
Dont worry about the mangas they usually have the same style or magic the anime have the only difference is they r in black & white(Sometimes they r better than the anime).
And don't worry about the name thing, i googled it and its apparently correct both ways
.
Dont worry about the mangas they usually have the same style or magic the anime have the only difference is they r in black & white(Sometimes they r better than the anime).
And don't worry about the name thing, i googled it and its apparently correct both ways
Posted Jun 11, 2008 1:53 pm PT
Yea yea I know.>.> It's just like tomorrow when it comes out and I can't cram through 3 games that fast.
MGS4 is definitely going to get some shelf time before I play it.>.>....
Posted Jun 11, 2008 2:52 pm PT
MyAnimeList.net would be my favorite place to find anime... only problem with it is that it easily gets you addicted to finding new ones.
And about the Berserk cliffhanger... damn. *shakes head*
And about the Berserk cliffhanger... damn. *shakes head*
Posted Jun 11, 2008 3:13 pm PT
Common theme? I dunno I've seen quite a bit of it, but not enough to call it common... unfortunately
Posted Jun 11, 2008 3:31 pm PT
[This message was deleted at the request of the original poster]
Posted Jun 12, 2008 2:20 am PT
I really wish Berserk was finished more than half the manga was left out. On top of Elfin lied and Berserk i also seen Tenjho Tenge whichs ends when the shows was gettin good such a bummer
Posted Jun 21, 2008 8:59 pm PT
If you liked this you should definately give Higurashi no Naku Koro ni a try, although NOTHING can beat The Melancholy of Haruhi Suzumiya imho!
Tengen Toppa Gurren Lagann also won 2008 TV Series of the year and is my current fav of 2008, give it a squizz!
Posted Jun 22, 2008 11:36 pm PT
Elfen Lied FTW!
And yes....the cliffhanger ending sucked
I've read the first few chapters of the manga and the art style is different, but that pic is misleading >_>
Posted Jun 25, 2008 9:18 am PT
^^^^ Did it still have a bunch of blood and nudity in the same style as the show did? (give or take the fan-favors.
)
Posted Jun 25, 2008 2:49 pm PT
o trust me its over, seen this like last year, was a little shock as to how short it was and the ending was somewhat a mystery
Posted Jul 18, 2008 7:08 pm PT
The manga has a couple of differences with the anime, but it is pretty good overall
Posted Aug 18, 2008 4:16 pm PT
no, I'd say Death Note's pretty awesome
Posted Aug 19, 2008 10:55 am PT
I cant read books anymore... gives me a headache. Your lucky
Posted Sep 13, 2008 12:21 pm PT
Elfen Lied is an awesome anime and manga!!
Posted Nov 11, 2008 9:34 am PT
I never got into that one for some reason...
Posted Jun 25, 2009 9:24 am PT
Page
1
« prev
|
next »
Friends
My Friends
Hungry_bunny
It's been a long time since I saw Elfen Leid but I still remember a lot. I remember having a theory that the person returning wasn't Lucy but Nyu... Lucy only said she wouldn't return...
Not sure about the manga, never picked it up. I think it's good but one of the things that I liked about the anime was that it was short, but I think the manga is 12 volumes which sounds like a lot more story (I think a couple of chapters would be enough for an anime episode).