GAMES: GameSpot GameFAQs MOVIES: Metacritic Movietome Comic-Con
Sunday, Sep 6, 2009

I am sick and tired of a largely overhyped game forcing its way into my mind and somehow on its way onto my shelf next to my small-but-proud collection of games!

This seemingly random rant comes to you today because of my most recent trip to Gamestop! Yay! You see, I was having a bad day and I needed something that would allow me to blow a thing up or two that was fresh. Now you all know I have pretty high standards, so long story short, I decided to buy the extremely-underhyped Civilization Revolution for the Xbox360.

Now, I didn't have any money to buy this, so I needed to get some money, so obviously it was time to get rid of some hype and one game I didn't want anymore;

The Hype:

Resident Evil 5

Fire Emblem: Shadow Dragon

Star Wars: The Force Unleashed

Old Game:

Pokemon Diamond (Tch, I have Platinum now...)

I ended up getting twice the amount I needed to buy my game. First things first, though. Those of you who know my insane almost-fanboy-ish love for the RE franchise would be shocked to see my classification of it as; "Hyped". Here's why:

The Story was mediocre

The Gameplay didn't change

The Voice Acting was shotty at some parts

The Game was criminally short

The Price tag was too high

I should not have pre-ordered it

I beat it in two days

It was horrible

Huge dissapointment

I wanted to be a zombie so Sheva would shoot me

Wesker was a wuss

I bought the versus mode only to find out the data was encrypted on the disk already

The game sucked

It was horrible

It reminded me of Sonic '06

Sorry, those were becoming opinions. Anyway, for some reason that game got onto my shelf. And I was wondering at first, how I bought it in the first place without reading any reviews, and then after reading reviews, I wondered, why does this game suck?

So I have a theory. Let's say, for instance, Mass Effect 2 sucks (Which it had BETTER NOT! This is an EXAMPLE people!) will you still buy it after playing the simply magnificent and gripping first installment?

To be honest, I would.

This is my theory: when a good game is released, its publishers immediately look at two things; sales and fanbase. Since we all know what I mean by sales I'll just go into fanbase; does the game have an affect on the gaming industry and the players in it? If both of these things look positive, it's time for a sequel.

For the fanbase, which is essentially us normal gamers, the company will do as much as it can to make you excited for the game. This can be shown largely through Bungie's Halo 3 launch, it was undeniably the biggest video game launch in history, and I'm not just talking about Sales, lines were formed that were hours long to get the game, people skipped work to play it, Hell it made the news because of that! Reviewers threw perfect scores at it without a second thought, and in the end, what did we get? A mediocre story with decent multiplayer. Oh, and pants-on-head-retarded AI (10 points to whomever caught the reference).

The companies hugely invest in the hope that the fans will instantly fall in love with whatever screenshots of the sequel they release and rumors that their company "accidentally" leaks about the game. This makes a game almost mouth-watering for us gamers, a good example of this would be Super Smash Bros. brawl. Who else went on smashbros.com every weekday to see the update, and always practically praying you would see the, "Challenger Approaching!" banner across the screen? I did.

So, when a game is finally released, it's up to reviewers to tell us if it's good or not. And I'm starting to wonder if it matters, the game is still going to be bought by those who hyped it to no end before its release, and people who just like the box design are going to buy it, too.

Let me ask a simple question, if it got bad reviews, would you buy;

Mass Effect 2?

Bioshock 2?

Halo: ODST?

Pokemon Heart Gold/ Soul Silver?

Final Fantasy XIII?

Kingdom Hearts: 358/2 days?

CODMW2?

GoW3?

The Beatles: Rock Band?

All of these games are getting hyped to no end, and generating a bigger fanbase every day. Would it matter to you if they really got bad scores?

Does hype get to reviewers? The first Halo changed shooters forever, in a way that would make 80% of any shooter that came out after that a clone of it, and reviewers would criticize it. But when Halo 3 came out, which changed nothing from the original in terms of gameplay (I mean, seriously, it's the THIRD installment! FIX IT!) it was praised for everything it had, which was essentially nothing different from the other two minus a few new maps and an even worse story.

So, back to my trip to Gamestop, I was asked if I planed to pre-order Halo 3: ODST or COD4MW2, and if I did I would get an extra $25 of my trade-ins put towards them, but I now wonder; why not any other game available to pre-order? Who else can't wait to get Scribblenauts? I asked about that and the clerk gave me a stupid look, I said, "These games are just being overhyped even more by promotions like this, but when games deserving of such a promotion like Scribblenauts comes around, you forget it even exsists." I understand the marketing strategy there, but seriously, who else thinks Batman: Arkham Asylam is not as great as everyone says?

I have fallen for hype too many times in the past, in fact the only time I resisted it was for Too Human, and I don't exactly know how I did, but I asked for a refund on my pre-order.

Comments

Page 1 
« prev  |  next »
Because hype makes us excited for the things we want.
Posted Sep 7, 2009 12:05 am PT
Ok, here are a few things I have to say. Without hype, there would be no reason we gamers would look forward for. Not many popular games can get their sequels releases without hype. Besides, my hype for halo is high and will keep rising until they kill off Master Chief. If Halo 3: ODST got a bad review, I wouldn't mind. Halo is halo to me. So long as it makes sense to me, i don't care if they rename it. Tell me, who is more hyped? Me with Halo or you with Mass Affect or Pokemon. Speaking of pokemon, this game hasn't changed much from it's previous games, don't you think that's repetitive? Just throwing it out there.
Posted Sep 7, 2009 4:03 am PT
Hype has gotten out of hand in recent years. I mean it seems like the only way to get perfect 10s nowadays is to be an overhyped sequel and it gets to the point where it's impossible for a game to live up to expectations and people are inevitably disappointed. It's bad when Spore gets an 8/10 and was still considered a major diappointment.
God knows I listened to all the whines of Nintendo fanboys when the final SSBB list was revealed and Megaman, Cloud, etc. weren't on it.
This is why I don't buy into hype mostly I'm not into the big titles that everyone gushes over outside the Nintendo parameters. That's why I like the games we discuss in "Under the Radar" because they're good games that aren't overhyped.
Posted Sep 7, 2009 4:27 am PT
People need something to get excited about and for us gamers that's games.
Posted Sep 7, 2009 5:24 am PT
I would probably still buy Kingdom Hearts even if it got bad reviews. I just love KH that much. Also, by any chance do you have anything against Batman: AA? Just curious.
Posted Sep 7, 2009 7:14 am PT
@Soldier629: I disagree. Scribblenauts is recieving no hype from what I can see, and the game simply looks addictive and fantastic. The difference between Halo and Pokemon is that;

A. Pokemon has a bigger fanbase
B. Pokemon at least throws a few mixes in the battle formula (Double Battles appeared) and brought on the Battle Tower for special rules. While the core gameplay hasn't changed, it still managed to improve.

@Kbaily: Then I assume Scribblenauts is on your list?

@TwilightSoldier: Yes and no. The game is really short and rediculously overhyped, but I still think it's a good game.
Posted Sep 7, 2009 7:37 am PT
Meh... hype's OK.
Posted Sep 7, 2009 8:06 am PT
Yeah, you do get really hyped up over games sometimes . But it's so true, hype really can affect whether or not people buy a game. That's why a lot of awesome games (Meteos, Elite Beat Agents, Okami, etc.) go under the spotlight. They didn't have the insane hype buildup Modern Warfare 2 is getting. If only we could get an extra $25 off Scribblenauts .
Posted Sep 7, 2009 9:26 am PT
@Thunderstarter:
Well Scribblenauts is a DS game. Not many DS games get a hype. Hardcore gamers get their hype from console games. Portable games hardly scratch the surface. My hype for kingdom hearts is still here, but I plan on waiting for Kingdom Hearts 358/2 days when I feel like getting it. Until the 3rd comes out, not for a while, my hype for halo is still the highest. Even though Kingdom Hearts is my all time favorite game.
Posted Sep 7, 2009 9:51 am PT
I might buy Heart Gold/Soul Silver. It depends on if there's enough of a difference between the originals and the remakes. For instance, I kinda hate FireRed/LeafGreen because there's almost no difference whatsoever, so they feel mediocre by today's standards. The originals, however, were great games for their time, so even playing them today they feel great. IT's a psychological thing.

I know Shadow Dragon was overhyped, but was it still good?

One of my favorite under-hyped games is Spyro: Season of Flame for the GBA. It has all the functions Season of Ice had, but it improved upon them and added more great stuff. The only problem is that the enemies' hit boxes are too small, and some of the mini-games are just down-right frustrating. By the way, before Kbaily starts ranting about how horrible Spyro has become (), this game is actually good, and isn't full of fart-jokes. It's not as good as the first three, but...

You have to admit that over-hyped games can still be good. For instance, Halo 3 doesn't deserve even 1/6 of its hype, but it's still enjoyable. Platinum had hype up the butt, and even if it really was just another variation over Diamond and Pearl, it's still enjoyable. FF7 is hyped as the greatest FF ever, and even though it really isn't, its still fun. I think you get the point, not that you weren't already aware of all this.

Also: SSBB is almost as over-hyped as Halo 3. Just sayin'.
Posted Sep 7, 2009 10:02 am PT
Some games are over hyped a little bit. Some games I have like Kingdom Hearts Re: Chain of Memories didn't get good reviews and I still bought it, and I enjoy it. You can't listen to every single review, that is my belief. Also as much as I like Resident Evil 5, I respect that you were honest about the game.
Posted Sep 7, 2009 11:12 am PT
I personally don't go by bad reviews (ESPECIALLY if its Gamespot cause I disagree with 80% of their reviews on Wii games ), they're Opinions. So yeah I still would get KH358/2 Days if it got a bad review
Posted Sep 7, 2009 1:00 pm PT
Where was it hyped? Whenever I went on the forums it was always halo this or Modern Warfare that, I actually thought it was a little under hyped. Although, I will admit AA was too short, even after I solved all the riddler challenges. I got a hour or two more fun with the Joker challenges though.
Posted Sep 7, 2009 4:01 pm PT
The Story was mediocre- Yes it was.

The Gameplay didn't change- Umm it added a Partner/Co-op.......

The Voice Acting was shotty at some parts- Yes

The Game was criminally short- No Batman is Short with little replay value, If you actually go back find everything beat it on all 4 difficultys, Got all the guns Maxed Out I still havent even gotten all S Ranks....

The Price tag was too high- For RE? No for Godfather, Gh Smash Hits, The list goes on

I should not have pre-ordered it- True

I beat it in two days- Do Ever think of re Playing it?

It was horrible- 8.5, Loads of Replay Value I almost got a Platinum.... Huge dissapointment- Story Wise Cant Argue there.....

I wanted to be a zombie so Sheva would shoot me- Wat? Sheva couldnt hit a zombie at point blank...

Wesker was a wuss- Yup

I bought the versus mode only to find out the data was encrypted on the disk already- It was 5 dollars ofcourse it was on the disc.......

The game sucked- I got my moneys worth

It was horrible- ok we get it .....

It reminded me of Sonic '06- No your smoking somthing. Comparing RE to a New Sonic Game?

On The Hyped game list all those games will be amazing, ODST maybe not so much but I think its going to be better then H3 with the FigherFight mode and all... And Yes Halo 3 sucked........ Dont Hate Me NF30.....
Posted Sep 8, 2009 12:32 pm PT
I'd definitely get 358/2 Days even if it had bad reviews. I don't pay too much attention to reviews because I stick with buying games from a few select companies and almost always get a game I like. I actually can't think of any time I bought a game I dislike. I will admit that we over-hype things a lot, but I'm generally pleased with the games that I am hyped for. Brawl was one of the games that I was a little disappointed in. For the first 30 hours or so I thought it was amazing, but I slowly got bored of it. I still like Brawl, but it was hyped.
Posted Sep 8, 2009 5:41 pm PT
@Soldier629: Again I disagree. FFIV DS, Chrono Trigger, GoWCOO, BOTH of the KH games coming out, Pokemon Diamond/Pearl/Platinum, Metal Gear Solid: Peace Walker, Scribblenauts, FE: SD, Resistance, SWBF:Renegade Squadron, Patapon 2, Clank, Daxter, the list goes on about hyped PSP and DS games, and hardcore is not defined by what games players play, but the passion that goes into the industry from them.

@Haga11111: Fire Emblem: SD was good but by no means worthy of its hype, I was really saddened by the poor quality of the story. I didn't buy into the Platinum hype, and I never played Season of Flame!

@Narutofan30: I don't consider co-op a HUGE change in gameplay, and I beat the game about...eh...5 times? And Sheva COULD shoot a zombie if you controlled her!
Posted Sep 10, 2009 7:38 pm PT
Well i dont understand why you dont like it you beat it 5 time some games i gont beat and just go back to COD. And if adding CO-OP, A Parter System and Online arent a CHANGE for you i dont know................ Shes not hiting the Zombie YOU are, she just flat sucks as a character in mine and most people opinion........
Posted Sep 11, 2009 3:21 am PT
Page 1 
« prev  |  next »
  • Thunderstarter
  • Level: 1 (0%)
  • Rank: Mogwai
  • Forum Posts: 1127
  • Messages Read: 0


advertisement

Friends

My Friends