As I expected, 12 won in the gameplay category, but not because I didn't try hard.  12 has a very good gameplay system, but I find the rest of the game boring and lacking... not a lot of stuff to do but hunts (more fighting) and a bunch of fetch missions... bleh. 

Next!  Story battle!  I think we got this one in the bag... but I still gotta show the judges I'm right... here I go..