GAMES: GameSpot GameFAQs MOVIES: Metacritic Movietome Comic-Con
Sunday, Oct 18, 2009

Last night, I finished Brütal Legend, a game I got last Tuesday. After witnessing all of the tremendous amount of hype surrounding Tim Schafer's heavy metal epic, I was anxious to play through the campaign as superstar roadie Eddie Riggs. Sadly, after an hour or so into the main storyline, my anxiety turned into frustration and disappointment.

As I mentioned, the game starts off with a bang. In fact, if you've played the demo, you know exactly how the game starts off. The first couple of missions after that are pretty cool, as you'll go around fighting off General Lionwhyte's army, all the while recruiting headbangers and others to join your own army, known as Ironheade. The story moves along at a brisk and steady pace until you get to fight Lionwhyte himself. Shortly after that, it slows down to a crawl while you partake in strung-out real-time strategy battles against the Drowned Doom and, finally, Doviculus' army. Although the story is quite good, I felt it was sacrificed along the way for the game's shady gameplay, which seems quite uncharacteristic of Tim Schafer.

Let's talk about that gameplay aspect for a moment. Brütal Legend implements real-time strategy elements, action elements, sandbox elements, role-playing game elements, racing elements and fighting elements, but never quite succeeds at either one of those. It's good to have ambition, but sometimes it's also good to know your limits. The side missions are a total bore and very repetitive. However, I found myself completing each and every one of them (except for the hunting ones) so I could accumulate enough Fire Tributes to upgrade my stuff. Those upgrades would become useless once the RTS gameplay kicked in, which made the side missions seem like a waste of time in the end.

Thankfully, that's not all Brütal Legend has to offer. The game does a great job in paying its respects to heavy metal, as it features a solid soundtrack with over 100 metal songs, and the metal infused world of Bladehenge, where monuments were erected in tribute to the Gods of Metal. There's also the superb cast of characters, including Jack Black as the main protagonist, a surprisingly fluent Ozzy as the Guardian of Metal, Lemmy Kilmister as the Kill Master, Rob Halford as General Lionwhyte and the marvelous Tim Curry as Doviculus.

In the end, however, I am brutally disappointed in Brütal Legend. For a game designed by a man whom I consider to be one of the greatest of all time, it hits somewhat of a sour note. The world, story and characters are quite awesome, but they are overshadowed by bad and indecisive gameplay. I haven't touched the multiplayer aspect, and I don't think I ever will. I feel like I've played enough of it in the campaign. Oh well, better luck next time, Tim.

Category: Games
Posted by NeoJedi, 11:53am
19 Comments | Post a Comment

Comments

Page 1 
« prev  |  next »
Never played it
Posted Oct 18, 2009 12:04 pm PT
Sorry to hear you didn't lke it.
Posted Oct 18, 2009 12:57 pm PT
Funny.. A friend of mine says this game is amazing. I played the demo, and was interested by it, but the fighting mechanic seemed very last-gen to me.
Posted Oct 18, 2009 1:33 pm PT
I don't have enough time to go and buy it right now, but I'm actually still interested in it. I'll pick it up in a few months for a reduced price.
Posted Oct 18, 2009 1:43 pm PT
I love the game, most of the people I know that dont like it too much aren't that good at strategy games tho...
Posted Oct 18, 2009 1:58 pm PT
Haven't played it but I've watched all the gameplay videos out there and to be honest I never saw what warranted the hype in the first place aside from Tim Schafer's name behind the box and the comedic element. Seems like a solid title though, but average. Hell I'll go on the record as saying that it's comparable to his previous game Psychonauts. It was a game popularized by its world, theme and humor but from a gameplay perspective it was rather traditional imo (collecting, platforming etc).
Posted Oct 18, 2009 2:10 pm PT
Enjoyed the demo and may pick this up at the end of this year or next year sometime.
Posted Oct 18, 2009 2:29 pm PT
Despite the hype with this game, I was never really excited about it. Nothing too exciting about what looks like a "typical action game". The demo basically reinforced my initial impressions of Brutal Legend. Sorry you were disappointed, bud. Nothing is worse than being excited about a game only to be let-down with the final result.
Posted Oct 18, 2009 2:43 pm PT
@LEGOslayer: Then, they shouldn't do false advertising in every single player gameplay video I've seen and promote it as a hack & slash game... and yes, I'm not that good at RTS.
Posted Oct 18, 2009 3:15 pm PT
Thank you for the honest mini review! I personally was not going to get it anyhow... but now I see more reasons to stay away from it.
Posted Oct 18, 2009 3:44 pm PT
I haven't played it but I've heard that it was pretty good, I guess you thought differently.
Posted Oct 18, 2009 3:56 pm PT
I was never hyped for Brutal Legend. Also, if you review the game can we please avoid the "brutally disappointed?" It's just too obvious, y'know?

But yeah, seeing the game in action, it looks funny, but it isn't something I'd ever pay $60 for. $5-$10, maybe. And I can see this game going for that price at some point for a brand new copy. And I'll purchase it then if the mood strikes me.
Posted Oct 18, 2009 8:02 pm PT
Ouch thats harsh but I think all valid points. I am thinking about getting it but this is the 2nd bad blog I have ead in less then 5 mins on this game. I might just weight on this one. Poor Tim!!!!
Posted Oct 18, 2009 11:07 pm PT
I was interested in the game, but the strategy elements didn't really appeal. And apparently, it makes up a significant portion of the game. Still, admirable to attempt a game like this. I don't think I've ever played an A-grade game that manages to successfully implement elements of different genres together. Sometime in the future perhaps.
Posted Oct 19, 2009 5:31 am PT
After trying out the demo I was very interested but I decided to wait to buy it. I'll probably buy it next year when the release fever is gone and its price will have dropped a bit.
Sorry that you were disappointed, but even that happens with games we think we're going to really adore.
Posted Oct 19, 2009 7:28 am PT
I've only heard good things so far so i'm sorry to hear you didn't like it
Posted Oct 19, 2009 9:53 am PT
It's ok to be disappointed with the game. I'm a big Tim Schafer fan but this is the first game that I'm really not looking forward to it because I find it to be overrated. The hype and the whole advertising was way overdone and I find it annoying when everyone was talking about it like it's some kinda Holy Grail. I haven't played the game yet and I'm in no rush to play it because of the reasons mentioned earlier. Plus I'm not a big fan of sandbox and open world kinda games. I'm more into straightforward and straight-to-the-point games like Grim Fandango, Full Throttle and Day of The Tentacle. Maybe I'll pick this up in months to come.
Posted Oct 19, 2009 2:02 pm PT
Just checked out that track list from the game. Man, Iced Earth and Children of Bodom would be full of win. But... There's no Opeth...
Posted Oct 20, 2009 5:43 pm PT
Couldn't agree more. I wish the demo had the RTS in it, I would've waited for the game to drop in price. It starts out as a game that if I was queried about what I like, that's how it would end up; cars, killing, and heavy metal!
Posted Nov 6, 2009 4:51 am PT
Page 1 
« prev  |  next »
  • NeoJedi
  • Level: 1 (0%)
  • Rank: Mogwai
  • Forum Posts: 12591
  • Messages Read: 0


advertisement

Friends

My Friends