Just like the whole "Buzz on Maggie is like the Replacements" situation, we've got another pair of two shows that are being compared like crazy and yet, THEY'RE NOTHING ALIKE!! And those two shows are iCarly and Hannah Montana.
Why are iCarly and Hannah Montana different? Because first of all, Carly is not spoiled and obnoxious like Miley is, Oliver is no where near as dorky as Freddie is and there's no way in a billion years that Lilly would beat up an innocent boy like Sam did in the pilot for iCarly.
Another example would be the iCarly episode "iHatch Chicks". Hannah Montana would have never gotten that dramatic if it did an episode like that. And look at how many "Tearjerker" reviews the iCarly episode "iWanna Stay with Spencer" got, even when it was only the fifth episode of the series! Hannah Montana didn't get that emotional that early. Not even for the entire first season. And if any of the first season episodes did get "Tearjerker" reviews, iWanna Stay with Spencer got more than all of the first season episodes of Hannah Montana got combined.
This is why I said that iCarly is more like That's So Raven because of all the melodrama in iCarly. While Hannah Montana had almost NO drama in its first season. And you all know that iWanna Stay with Spencer was only the fifth (out of the 25 first season episodes) episode of iCarly and you all still cried hard over that. And yet, it's STILL like Hannah Montana?! That just doesn't make sense to me. Hannah Montana didn't get that dramatic that early in the series. That's So Raven got that dramatic that early.
And finally, there's a "Ships" situation. Seddie has like 50 times as much supporters as Creddie does while Moliver and Loliver have the EXACT SAME AMOUNT OF SHIPPERS. The only thing that can fix this is either if more of the Seddie fans went over to Creddie to get the exact same amount of shippers for each one or say, Loliver fans transport over to Moliver so that one ship would have more fans than the other.
And so, with all that said, just face it. Comparing iCarly to Hannah Montana is kinda like comparing Full House to 8 Simple Rules. Sorry if I might have insulted anybody about anything listed here. I didn't mean to. I just had to get that out in the open. But anyway, there's my thesis right there. Laters.
Comments
DisneyFreak33 (2): Exactly! People who hate TBOM and barely know anything about it say it's automatically like "Replacements" when they're nothing alike!
DisneyFreak33