GAMES: GameSpot GameFAQs MOVIES: Metacritic Movietome Comic-Con
Friday, Nov 30, 2007

Jeff Gerstmann and I got to work together at GameSpot for 10 years. It seems he didn't get a chance to properly say goodbye here this week. This is simply the opinion of a longtime fan of this site: As the longest-tenured GameSpot editor, Jeff Gerstmann deserved a respectful send-off.

My last day at GameSpot was pretty good. It was on a Tuesday early this year. I had already packed up my stuff, had already told my team I was leaving and where I was going and what I was going to do next, and that I believed in them. What I really wanted to do was put in one last day's work at the site. I shot a video review, submitted and prepared a few pieces of content including a final review of mine, met with my closest colleagues, made my rounds with some of the others I'd always wished I got to talk to more, and tied up what seemed like a last few loose ends. I had a brief exit interview as well. It was an oddly liberating experience. As great as it was to work at GameSpot, I rarely felt a sense of closure at the job, because there was always lots more work to be done and more I could have been doing. The game industry never stops, and there are always more games I could be playing. It occurred to me that most of the closure I'd been feeling over the past decade came from finishing games.

I shouldn't lump myself into the same category as Jeff because we're pretty different people in spite of us having the same feelings about games and similar perspectives on a lot of subjects related to games. But I think guys like him and me see closure as a nice-to-have. We'd rather be moving on to our next assignment. So I said my goodbyes here in January not to provoke and get off on the generous flattery provided by a subset of people who took the time to respond, but to provide what I considered to be a basic, human courtesy to all those people who were familiar with my work over time. Some of those people hated my guts for all I knew--they had a right to know I was leaving same as anyone else. So then, to those of you familiar with Jeff's work: You should rest assured he'd take the opportunity to do what I did, not because we presume to know it's the "right" thing to do, but because we basically trust our instincts. It's not hard--it's rather easy--to imagine him saying goodbye here in his own way. And I have every faith that we'll be hearing from him again soon. I look forward to that moment.

As for the rest of the team that makes GameSpot's content: What you do next is more important than what you've done already. Every day you should be reminding yourselves that, because of the magic of the Internet, someone could just flip a switch that causes everything you've ever done here to just vanish. But the influence of your actions never disappears, and whatever integrity or credibility this site has gathered over the years is due to your hard work. I have no right to telling you what to do. But as a user of this site, I've come to expect a lot, and I know you listen.

Master Chief says it best: "We'll be fine."

And that's all I wanted to say here and I don't have anything more to add.

Category: Games
Posted by GregK, 10:34pm
194 Comments | Post a Comment

Comments

Page 1  2  3  4 
« prev  |  next »
Thank you for the comment Greg, we've all been eagerly waiting to hear what you would have to say about this entire situation. Why? You're an extremely well respected Game reviewer yes, but thats not the reason. You, Jeff, Rich, Carrie, Alex,Thor, and the others are the heart and soul of Gamespot. The users are the icing on the cake. As long as we as individuals don't loose our integrity, and continue being the people you are, then the Gamespot spirit will truly never die! Thanks for your kind comment Greg. My heart goes out to the remaining Cnet staff at gamespot.
Posted Nov 30, 2007 10:36 pm PT
I just wish Jeff had a better goodbye than being abruptly fired in a very controversial way. Greg, you've provided me with a great insight to this whole ordeal. I believe you've spoken out at a great time to give your input on the situation.
Posted Nov 30, 2007 10:37 pm PT
My god, Greg I have to say I was never a huge fan of yours back when I was lurking..I didn't agree with your review scores more often than not, but they were always well written and I can't fault you as a person or as a reviewer.

This whole thing is incredibly unfortunate and like everyone else I'm sad it happened..I'm just thankful for your powerful words on the subject.
Posted Nov 30, 2007 10:44 pm PT
Great post Greg. I hope Jeff isn't too torn about this.
Posted Nov 30, 2007 10:45 pm PT
It is good to hear from you Greg. The rumor is getting uglier and uglier everyday, and it's not just us, but every major game news outlet has picked it up, and every major game forums are building their own rumors as well. Why CNET still refuses to address the issue is puzzling.
Posted Nov 30, 2007 10:45 pm PT
Jeff provided so much for gamespot its a real damn shame stuff like this happens, Jeff really does deserves a proper send off.
Posted Nov 30, 2007 10:45 pm PT
Sigh it's sad to see how this is the end for alot of mebmers who visited this site for years like me. Gamespot was truly one of a kind gaming website but my stomache is so disgusted on what they did to Jeff. How could you do something like that for a person who's been loyal to your company for nearly 10+ years. It's nice to see you make a comment about this Greg but I really wish there was a way jeff could get his job back. Time to delete hotspot off my podcast and delete majority of gamespot bookmarks
Posted Nov 30, 2007 10:45 pm PT
I thought you would come back to say something about this. Glad you did!
Posted Nov 30, 2007 10:45 pm PT
I really hope we hear from Jeff soon. What was done to Jeff was just unfair in so many ways. I mean at leas they could have given him a proper sendoff. A man who has worked for 10 years with this company deserves at least that.
Posted Nov 30, 2007 10:46 pm PT
The community will always follow the team that has made Gamespot. Even if it's under a different name.

Any action they choose to take will be heavily empowered.
Posted Nov 30, 2007 10:46 pm PT
Thanks so much for weighing in Greg.

I think that even if credibility is lost, the community and staffers have enough to revamp this place. I am never going to leave, I promise that

I look forward to someday working for Gamespot and interviewing you about a future game

Come back more often, it would be nice to hear what you are up to! You are a celebrity, embrace it!
Posted Nov 30, 2007 10:46 pm PT
It is a sad day for Gamespot indeed. Everything we have been building up for seems to have been destroyed by one event. I hope Gamespot can be the community I know it is and find a way to endure this tradegy.
Posted Nov 30, 2007 10:47 pm PT
It's nice to hear what you and Alex think. I'm going to miss Jeff as I missed you but I feel bad at how Jeff was let go. I would like him to make just one last blog about how he feels and just to say goodbye.
Posted Nov 30, 2007 10:49 pm PT
To see someone such as yourself provide input on what's happened is a very, very, very nice thing. I'm still trying to really stomach what this means for the site as a whole and while I can guess what it could be like in theory, there's no way I can no without being a staffer, past or present. But nevertheless, seeing those words from the man I respect the most out of the entire gaming industry still manages to provide comfort. There is still some light within the darkness for those who love writing and gaming equally and I thank you for that from the depths of my heart.
Posted Nov 30, 2007 10:49 pm PT
Greg, you are a hero of mine, and always will be. Thank you for your message to us, and to the gamespot staff.
Posted Nov 30, 2007 10:53 pm PT
I have a great deal of respect for both you and Jeff. I was sad to see you leave the site, I believe you're among the best game review editors in the business.

Same with Jeff. However his send-off is even sadder, simply because of the circumstances surrounding his departure. He really does deserve better. I wish him the best of luck.
Posted Nov 30, 2007 10:55 pm PT
Greg this has been a sad day. Truly sad, Jeff was literally the heart and soul of Gamespot. There isn't really anything else
Posted Nov 30, 2007 10:58 pm PT
Wise words Greg, you and Jeff got me interested and ultimately now involved in the gaming community (I now write technology/gaming for a newspaper) and for that words are hard to come by that describe that kind of respect. I hope Jeff looks at this like opportunity, but I can't help but want to buy the man a beer for being treated in that manner. We'll all miss him.
Posted Nov 30, 2007 10:59 pm PT
I look forward to hearing from Jeff quite soon also.

The man is probably the most dedicated editor of the site.....the least that Cnet could do was give him a proper sendoff....
Posted Nov 30, 2007 11:01 pm PT
Good to hear from you mate.
Posted Nov 30, 2007 11:03 pm PT
Greg, once you left the CNET bigwigs decided that it would be okay to transition to their plan to expand the reader audience of gamespot by diminishing the autonomy of the editorial team for the sake of publishers' interests.

You were one pillar of gamespot. Jeff was the other. Once you left, Jeff couldn't hold them off on his own. Now he's been fired, and gamespot will never be the same again.

Shame on those money-hungry cowards who destroyed this beacon of gaming journalism, and the work you and Jeff put into building it all these years.

I hope they will pay dearly for what they've done.
Posted Nov 30, 2007 11:03 pm PT
Thanks for the post Greg, been awhile since we've heard from you. Best wishes to everyone at GameSpot, especially Jeff.
Posted Nov 30, 2007 11:06 pm PT
Greg, I was really hoping you'd say something about all of this. You have been totally missed, man. It's unfortunate things have turned out like this, but we all know Jeff will get back on his feet and be a success wherever he goes from here. This whole event is probably going to be turning Jeff into the most recognized game reviewer around. Though I'm not saying it isn't deserved, he's been a fanastic reviewer and a huge contribution to this site. That's not to say that you haven't been also, Greg. Don't worry. We haven't forgotten how awesome you are, man. Thanks for taking time to comment on all of this. Take care.
Posted Nov 30, 2007 11:07 pm PT
Kas, this is why we miss you. It frustrates me that your simple post here is the best thing I've read from GSpot in months. I don't know if I can truly wrap my head around the situation, but it just seems like things are on a downhill slide in general, and the way Jeff was treated certainly can't be indicative of improvements happening any time soon.

Am I wrong? I said this on Overwritten.net earlier today: "And considering they lost a guy who was more or less at the helm (Kas), who for all the simplicities of his job, was really a visionary in terms of... well, just being an *example* of exactly what game journalism should be, it shouldn't come as much surprise to see that bad things are happening there now."

If there's anything else you can do to guide the poor souls that remained after your departure, please do. Something just seems to be missing, and I feel like the once-trustworthy source where I could go to get real solid information that wasn't tainted or overblown or sensationalistic is turning into a carbon copy of all the other places that have gone this route in the past.

Bah. I'm getting sidetracked. Anyway, this is all just distressing in general, but so are the trends I've seen in game journalism of late. I hope Jeff manages to find other work soon (he will), as despite the fact that I never much cared for his work here, he put in the hours and was a decent fella. Nobody deserves this kind of treatment, much less without the opportunity for a proper goodbye to those they've served for so long.

Best of luck to you, Jeff. Best of luck to you too, Greg. And with the way trends seem to be going lately, best of damned luck to us all.
Posted Nov 30, 2007 11:13 pm PT
Thanks Greg. It's great to get your perspective on this. Hope you're doing well.
Posted Nov 30, 2007 11:14 pm PT
First, Ryu left getting better opportunity and now, Ken has been kicked for his true yet unorthodox ways.

Now Guile,Chunli and a few others are left...

let us see how this SF without Ryu and Ken goes.....
Posted Nov 30, 2007 11:15 pm PT
You don't know how good it is to hear from you again, Greg. There's a lot of us that care deeply about all this. Some of us will never forget the work put into this site.
Posted Nov 30, 2007 11:19 pm PT
it's a sad, sad day for gaming.
Posted Nov 30, 2007 11:21 pm PT
We could always get a roll of "Vive El Jeffe" stickers and plaster them around the C|NET offices.
Posted Nov 30, 2007 11:25 pm PT
And again, all I can say is "Damn."
Posted Nov 30, 2007 11:26 pm PT
Greg, you're still the man. Nice post.
Posted Nov 30, 2007 11:30 pm PT
I stand up for Gamespot when I hear about people complaining about reviews, and this is what I've been standing up for? A company that hangs its senior editor out to dry to keep the small fish in line when he plays it straight and gives an honest opinion that the gaming companies don't appreciate?

Bah. Man, I miss the good days with you guys, and I'll remember the day I managed to finagle my boss at work into allowing me to tune into the Oblivion marathon you were broadcasting. It wasn't the same here when you left, and tomorrow will bring more of the same with Jeff gone. It's sad when it's not about the games anymore. It's good to hear from you again, Greg. Thanks for giving Jeff a send-off, even though he deserves much more than just you could give.
Posted Nov 30, 2007 11:32 pm PT
This whole "chain of events" kind of reminds me of Alan Moore's Watchmen. Anyway I really agree with Quemaqua, your recent editorial really is the best thing I've read in the past couple of months here at Gamespot. It was really getting pretty sombre here and this whole Jeff getting canned thing doesn't help the situation at all, if the rumors are true (and by all indications they just might be) the video-game industry has arrived to that point where it all starts to tumble down that painfully bumpy slide of sleaziness. I just wonder what this might spell for the developers.
Posted Nov 30, 2007 11:34 pm PT
Come back Greg! We miss you.
Posted Nov 30, 2007 11:45 pm PT
Oh man. After so long, reading a Greg Kasavin post is like seeing Optimus Prime come out of hibernation with plans to save the world.

Thanks for adding to the proceedings Greg. You're still missed, and I continue to look forward to an imminent EA release with your name on the cover, completely dwarfing the relevance of the game's title.
Posted Nov 30, 2007 11:49 pm PT
Ever since the forum change and all the glitches started popping up, it's been turning me off aesthetically.

The community was already sliding then, getting too big and gray, losing its personality, and now with this the whole site's just an ugly blob of a mess.
Posted Nov 30, 2007 11:51 pm PT
I've already pronounced judgment of the site, but I don't think GameSpot is irredeemable. I don't know if the staff has the power to right the wrongs that have been wrought, but if they can, they have all the respect in the world from me.

This is precisely the right thing to be said; it's true, and it covers the story from an angle that's being forgotten. You have always had my respect, Mr. Kasavin, but after this post, I just respect you all that much more.
Posted Nov 30, 2007 11:52 pm PT
I want to know what love is.
Posted Nov 30, 2007 11:57 pm PT
for some reason greg , you always know what to say and how to say it , to make everything better . thats what i always enjoyed about your work . it appears that its never stopped .
Posted Dec 1, 2007 12:03 am PT
Thanks Greg...the My Little Pony(tm) avatar helps to ease my pain as well.
Posted Dec 1, 2007 12:06 am PT
Thanks for the words, Greg. Hope everything is going fine with you and hope everything turns out well in the end for Jeff.
Posted Dec 1, 2007 12:11 am PT
Posted Dec 1, 2007 12:27 am PT
I miss you greg
Posted Dec 1, 2007 12:37 am PT
Bring back the old GameSpot!!!!

Oh what the future brings!!
Posted Dec 1, 2007 12:39 am PT
Well said Greg. You were the reason I stuck with the site and fell in love with it. This site has changed a lot in the last two years and the sudden departure of Jeff is one of the most shocking moments the site has ever faced. Gamespot will live on and I promise to be here.
Posted Dec 1, 2007 12:41 am PT
It was yours and Jeff's reviews that I really trusted and enjoyed, so without either of them I have the pretty sad feeling that this site is going to feel pretty desperate and hollow.
Posted Dec 1, 2007 12:48 am PT
I need a long shower after today here at GS, the whole thing is a slimy mess. Good to see a blog entry from you, Greg, even if the circumstances are crappy.
Posted Dec 1, 2007 12:49 am PT
Just think of what the atmosphere at the gamespot office must be like after this mess. Each time someone leaves gamespot becomes more soulless because its not the games that make this site what it is but instead the colourful personalities of its staff. You dont know what you've got till its gone.
Posted Dec 1, 2007 12:55 am PT
Uh, wow. It's great to hear from you Greg, and it's even better to hear you talking about what has been on all of our minds as well.
Posted Dec 1, 2007 12:55 am PT
Page 1  2  3  4 
« prev  |  next »
  • GregK
  • Level: 1 (0%)
  • Rank: Mogwai
  • Forum Posts: 153
  • Messages Read: 0


advertisement

Friends

My Friends