GAMES: GameSpot GameFAQs MOVIES: Metacritic Movietome Comic-Con
Friday, Oct 16, 2009

In light of this article, I was surprised to see how many people are out there openly and willingly justify piracy. For those who don't know, a device out there allows free and easy downloading and running of illegal copies of Nintendo DS games. (To avoid potential moderation, I'm not going to say its name here but it's covered in GS's article). Naturally, Nintendo and other companies are fighting a possibly hopeless battle to see this device removed from the market. What's crazy though is how many people support the device's usage, finding whatever way they could to justify it.

Some say people pirate games because they're "too expensive" or "overpriced", and used it as an opportunity to bash Nintendo because they think the "Big N" doesn't deserve the success it enjoys through the Wii and DS. But these people would say the games are overpriced if they cost one cent each. Why? Because they think they shouldn't have to pay for anything. That's why people steal in the first place…either they can't pay or refuse to pay for things that they should have to pay for.

One comment I read suggested the companies ask why people buy and use the devices. Like Ra's Al Ghul said in Batman Begins, a criminal is not complicated. It's not because games cost too much. It's not because games these days suck. It's not because Nintendo and Capcom are "evil". People use the device because it allows them to play games that they should have to buy, for free. That's it. If I walked up to a table and a man was there with two DS systems sitting there, and he told me "You have to pay for the one on the left, but you can take the one on the right for free, no questions asked", which one am I going to take? Of course, the free one. Why pay if I don't have to, right? That's the philosophy behind the average game pirate.

Some people try to make it seem all deep and psychological, but it's not. A cheap device you stick into your DS lets you play games you download without having to buy them. I don't know anything about homebrew applications, but I doubt very seriously people buy this device solely to play someone else's fan-made games, listen to MP3s or watch movies. Maybe 1 percent of those who use the device, maybe.

I found it insane that people actually expressed anger at Nintendo and Capcom for wanting to get the device taken off the market. I mean, how dare Nintendo actually want people to buy their products instead, right? The nerve of them to actually expect to sell products that take years worth of man-hours to develop and produce? How dare they think that just because they develop games, masterful amalgams of creativity, technological know-how and graphic design and put them on the market with intent to sell them, why should they actually expect to make money? I mean, it's not like they're a business or anything.

Except they are. And they have every right to want to make money off of their products. That's why they do what they do. And they have every right to do whatever they can to stop others from preventing them from profiting off of their hard work.

I bet most people who support the usage of the device have never designed a game or so much as written a line of code in their life. If they knew what kind of work goes into even the simplest games, they wouldn't dare pirate them. And as an artist studying Game Art and Design myself, I'm disgusted that people take such a casual attitude to this. It's no different from art theft.

Sure, it may be a losing battle for Nintendo and others, but it's still a battle that should be fought, and anyone who really claims to love video games and this industry would do well to support the downfall and destruction of devices that allow people to download and play games illegally, and the people who make and sell such devices.

Category: Editorial
Posted by Dualmask, 6:57am
16 Comments | Post a Comment

Comments

Page 1 
« prev  |  next »
I agree with everything you said... but I still want one to put all my legit games on so I don't have to keep swapping carts to play everything I own... I also want to use it as a mp3 player...
Posted Oct 16, 2009 7:47 am PT
@raahsnavj I suppose you're justified that way, but I can't say I agree totally. Nintendo didn't intend for the DS to be used as an MP3 player (not at least until they made the DSi) and backing up games is illegal if I recall. Sure, logically speaking, if you pay a certain amount of money for a game you want to protect that investment, but laws are laws...and I've read in plenty of places that when you buy a game, you don't actually own the copy of the game or have rights to it; you bought the authorization to play/use it within the boundaries of agreements in the manuals and such.

That's why people buy insurance for things like electronics, cars and homes. If something bad happens, someone has to get paid in order for that investment to be restored. Of course, I'm not suggesting taking out insurance for DS games, but...just saying.
Posted Oct 16, 2009 7:52 am PT
@raahsnavj I'm with you on that. In Korea, I saw a device that did just that. Many of my platoonmates had it. The Katusas had been using it for a couple of years already.

As far as MP3 on DSi, forget it. It uses AAC files, which are harder to come by/convert to. That's why I traded my DSi for a DSlite. At least the GBA games are playable on it.
Posted Oct 16, 2009 8:15 am PT
Very well written! It's nice to see a little support for the fight against piracy, to be quite honest. There's not too much I can add to your point that you haven't touched on, so I won't. Still, as long as there are those who feel like they can get away with something like this, they will, and if they can make themselves look innocent, they'll try to do whatever in their power to do so. Not everyone's like this, but we all know that there are still plenty of people who would take this route.

Personally, I've never touched a piracy device or a homebrew app in my life. Heck, I don't even like to cheat within games, let alone cheat in order to get them. Still, I'd like to think that I respect a designer's creative skills to truly support a product in someway if I'm interested in it. In this regard, it really isn't much different from the art world at all. I'm not really surprised you took this stand considering that.
Posted Oct 16, 2009 8:27 am PT
I wrote thousands and thousands of C++ lines and I still support piracy. The reason isn't all deep and psychological, it's just that I live in a country that don't give a damm about it so I'm completely safe. Then you get the best point ever... you get to play games for free, lol.

I don't feel bad for Nintendo, not because their recent games are heavy dose of suckage, but simply because of all that money they're doing with the Wii that covers the tiny-itchy loss of money caused by me.
Posted Oct 16, 2009 9:20 am PT
Oh and actually, homebrew applications on the Wii are pretty dang awesome compared to the DS. You can read movies off the DVD drive, burn multiple GameCube games on a single DVD (a few games aren't compatible with that, though), emulators for every 16-bit consoles that makes the Virtual Console obsolete, a savegame extractor, an action replay/gameshark for Wii and so much more... oh and there ARE very solid homebrew games out there.
Posted Oct 16, 2009 9:26 am PT
@Rovelius I suppose I didn't consider cultural differences. If I grew up in a country where such a practice is commonplace and ignored, I'd probably have a different attitude too. It's all in how we're brought up I suppose.

But I can't understand how someone who understands the effort that goes into games is fine with the act of stealing them.
Posted Oct 16, 2009 9:27 am PT
@nate1222 - that is why I want the homebrew app that lets me just play MP3's... none of this AAC file stuff.

@Dualmask - Well, I think that is the flaw video game companies are making. They want to own what they just sold me. They want it to be a rental service or a 'lock-in' where they can dictate the terms and tell me how to use it. They don't get that by being a dictator they just cause more people to want to rebel...

As for insurance... that just isn't a good topic for me. Insurance is bull created by people that didn't want to work for a living. By getting a whole bunch of people to each give you $5, you can then 'fix' one persons problem by leaching off the other people... it's like a happy group all looking out for each other while the guy in the middle takes 50% of the pot for his 'services'. meh, I hate insurance. Especially when I can provide myself with better value in a more reliable and efficient manner with no middle man.

It's like the laws are there to protect the inefficiencies of the world... so the dumb people can make a buck. Again though. I don't plan on pirating games. I will buy stuff that is for sale for the money asked. But I don't want to be told how to use my hardware.
Posted Oct 16, 2009 9:44 am PT
[This message was deleted at the request of the original poster]
Posted Oct 16, 2009 9:47 am PT
@Rovelius - But the VC isn't obsolete. You should still own the rights to what you play. Now, being able to finally play all the games for my SNES that haven't hit the VC yet. would be nice. I already own the game I don't feel like I need to shell out the money to play it again... Again this is legal mumbo jumbo though to double dip profits with...

yeah, it might just be culture differences though. one question for you though... who pays for your food and how?
Posted Oct 16, 2009 9:51 am PT
I collect some games that are factory sealed that I definitely don't want to open. If I play the backups of those games, am I still stealing? I could always buy a 2nd copy but sometimes it's just easier to play the roms. I agree though, it is still pirating and it's still illegal. I'm not denying that.
Posted Oct 16, 2009 1:48 pm PT
@Dualmask This is all just a discussion about morals and ethics, right? At some point, someone convinced you that stealing was a bad thing. And I think so too, don't get me wrong... I would feel bad if I stole from a shop (something I never did), stole from a house etc. but I don't think that stealing games is a bad thing. I support indie developers and free software for the people. Just go on Google and type "why free software", first page.

I don't hesitate to buy a game when needed though (I'm thinking Steam games) and so far the only games I got the pirated way are those I couldn't find in stores (or were overly priced because they're rare) like Plok, F-Zero GX, Suikoden and Brawl
Posted Oct 17, 2009 9:34 am PT
My Wii couldn't read my Brawl legit copy and since I'm in a part of the world where Nintendo doesn't offer their "free" repair services, I had to get myself a pirated copy that works on a DVD5 - a single layer one. I get the same game but I can't play on WiFi's With Anyone and every single cutscenes of the games are removed. Honestly, it's the day I popped in Brawl and saw it wasn't working than I thought "screw you Nintendo". We all know this was a dirty trick from them to keep the modded Wii's from playing Brawl. Mine wasn't chipped and I still couldn't play - how fair is that?
Posted Oct 17, 2009 9:39 am PT
[This message was deleted at the request of the original poster]
Posted Oct 17, 2009 10:10 am PT
@raahsnavj

That's pretty much the main reason why I said the VC was rendered obsolete. Playing games that aren't out on it yet. There's actually a modified channel out there for Smash 64, and it's still fun as ever to play. I bought over 20 games on it so far and I would most likely buy the games I got the bad way should they be on the VC someday.

That last question was irrelevant (please tell me how it is, as I don't see) and its answer none of your concern.
Posted Oct 17, 2009 10:10 am PT
@Rovelius - The last question is relevant to the point that people eat by spending the money they make by making games. The question was to the point of, however you get the money to eat your food, kill it because someone thought it wasn't worth paying for... that is what piracy does. You kill people's livelyhood.

Now from your other comments it would seem you make money from something else, not full time software development, as such you see no reason why all this software shouldn't be free. So you feel like you can steal someone else's ability to earn a living... I think it is bull.
Posted Oct 18, 2009 4:08 pm PT
Page 1 
« prev  |  next »
  • Dualmask
  • Level: 1 (8%)
  • Rank: Mogwai
  • Forum Posts: 457
  • Messages Read: 0


advertisement

Friends

My Friends