this new pie or cake thing is a tough one! cake is awesome and comes in lots of styles and flavors like one of my favorites ice cream cake! but oh my god! that pumpkin pie! i just cant stay away from it so i have to say they are both good and my favorite cake is ice cream cake and of course my favorite pie is pumpkin pie with whip cream on top! oh yeah! so i really dont know whats better but cake does have a advantage of way more flavors and stuff.