Either GTA4 or Metal Gear Solid. Its almost a matter of taste. Both games have beatiful stories. GTA 4 is a little more gritty. Maybe the deciding factor will be that gta is on two systems and mgs4 is only on one?

I personally think it will be GTA IV but MGS4 has a really goos shot...man it's getting harder and harder to truly say...I htink I'll stick with GTA IV though.

I love GTA IV, but MGS4 looks surefire to win. GTA IV though stands a great chance.

maybe gta4. but mgs4 is a real possibility

Well I'm sure that MGS4 has a much higher chance at winning. But I personally want Gears of War to win haha.

Prototype got pushed to 09, so that's not an option. not that it would have won anyway.

There might be an issue with release dates but no Spore, no LittleBigPlanet, no Fable 2?

What Prototype got pushed to 2009. Damn

I feel that if Spore delivers on it's many promises, it could be the favorite for GOTY.

Hmm maybe your right.

MGS 4. I think they will do it just because it's the last in the series. Plus does it even really matter? this year even some games that won't be nominated for GOTY could win any other year. Honestly 2007 might have had more blockbusters but this year definitely is even better than 2007 was, and it might be the best year in gaming general.

[This message was deleted at the request of the original poster]

i think the force unleashed might get a nomination cause the demo was awesome but i have never played those games you have up there

MGS4. GTA IV was completely overated for a 10.

I hope its mgs4. It was truly epic.

I got Star Wars Unleashed it was ok. But Dead Space is way better.

It's not on your list, but Fallout 3 will be game of the year to many, at least I think!

I think Metal Gear Solid 4 it's an Awesome Game .. But GTA IV though stands a Great Chance !