GAMES: GameSpot GameFAQs MOVIES: Metacritic Movietome Comic-Con
Saturday, Dec 1, 2007

If all the furore about Jeff being fired over his Kane & Lynch review is true, and I suspect that it is, it is a very dark day for Gamespot. Not only has the site lost one of its most entertaining and knowledgeable staff but it has seriously compromised its integrity into the bargain.

My trust in this site has decreased so much that It wouldn't surprise me to see some sort of Stalinist revisionism over the next few days where Dead Men miraculously gets re-reviewed and comes up smelling of roses on a bed of $$$$$$ signs. The whole thing stinks of CNET's corporate relationship with Eidos when it comes to advertising paychecks.

Kane & Lynch has been advertised on Gamespot so inexorably (the site was even re-skinned in K&L images for a while) that for Jeff to actually "tell it like it is" in the review meant he had to stick his neck out and put his head on the block. Unfortunately, to complete the analogy, the axe fell and it cost Jeff his job.

I'm glad that Jeff valued his personal integrity and respected us, the readers,enough not to just feed us some crap about K&L being awesome in order to keep the publishers happy. It seems Gamespot has been in gradual decline all year and it is currently joining the ranks of IGN in the untrustworthyness stakes.

Greg Kasavin, a voice of objective reason,left in jan 2007 and now Jeff gets sacked amid a hail of controversy for slamming a lazy game and not letting Eidos get away with selling us second rate crap. Who do we have left to stand up for gamers who actually give a damn about the quality of games? To the other reviewers, if you care- walk out- make this place a ghost town.

Although i'll keep this account to see what happens to Gamespot over the coming months (I predict further loss of integrity with reviewers running scared from the truth) I will be finding a new main site to read my gaming news and reviews from now on. Eurogamer looks like a possible alternative.

Next time you want to give an honest opinion when money is involved- remember what happened to ol' Jeff!

Posted by 7-ate-9, 8:06am
2 Comments | Post a Comment

Comments

Page 1 
« prev  |  next »
Conflict of interest for critics in any genre, whether it be movies, music, or games can be an interesting problem. Websites in particular have an interesting different climate from other mediums such as newspapers or magazines in that I think they can be sometimes even more of a victim to conflict of interest. Traditional journalism media forms have a much stronger moto to being indepedent and objective which websites tend to not follow as much sometimes. Although overall the internet is suppose to enhance our first amendment and democritization of the world. Reviews especially with video games carry huge weight nowadays in how consumers decide if they will make an investment or not. Unlike movies or music which are very subjective based on content, games can have clear flaws in their production because of being interactive and a product. Console games in particular are insanely overpriced now at $60, making it foolish for anyone not to do their research before spending that kind of cash. If critics lose their credibility it can very extremely damaging for their publication and readers. Their job is to make sure that developers create quality games instead flexing their marketing muscle to trap people in without knowing anything about it. What do you think about IGN? Are they gamespot's main critic comeptitor. I prefer websites myself that do not inflate their ratings and I wonder how Gamespot's new rating system which has simplified things into multiples of five has had an effect on this.
Posted Dec 21, 2007 11:07 pm PT
Well Alx Navarro is leaving too, all we need is for Ryan Davis to go and this site is over. Ryan should get out of here and set up something new with Alex and Jeff.
Posted Jan 13, 2008 5:44 am PT
Page 1 
« prev  |  next »
  • 7-ate-9
  • Level: 1 (0%)
  • Rank: Mogwai
  • Forum Posts: 61
  • Messages Read: 0


Friends

My Friends