All critic scores are converted to a 100-point scale. If a critic does not indicate a score, we assign a score based on the general impression given by the text of the review. Learn more...
Average User Score:




9
(25 sources)
Melrose was the second person out of the top three that I rooted for after Eugena lost. She was like so mean to Caridee at home, the photoshoot and at the runway. She doesn't have sympathy, but when she's at the bottom like her first photoshoot...
[+] Read Full Review
Melrose was the second person out of the top three that I rooted for after Eugena lost. She was like so mean to Caridee at home, the photoshoot and at the runway. She doesn't have sympathy, but when she's at the bottom like her first photoshoot she's desparate and crying. I do admire her courage to go on but she is fake and really overanalyzes. She takes great pictures but some of them like the covergirl shoot, she thinks too much. She has a great knowledge of fashion but she doesn't like her makeover and sometimes I wish she had sympathy for people. she still rocked the runway.
Posted jul 17, 2008 3:03 pm pt
I hate Melrose so much! She just bugged me and i wished she got out on the first elimination of America's Next Top Model. She was such a spoiled brat and a big b***h! She thinks she is so cool and she trys to make herself look cool but she isn's....
[+] Read Full Review
I hate Melrose so much! She just bugged me and i wished she got out on the first elimination of America's Next Top Model. She was such a spoiled brat and a big b***h! She thinks she is so cool and she trys to make herself look cool but she isn's. She even cryed ehen she lost to CariDee and said people were calling her a b***h through the game which is true. She wants people to feel sorry for her by crying. I have no idea why Tyra liked her. Even though she may be good at modeling i still hate her and I am so happy she didn't win!
Posted feb 7, 2007 9:51 am pt
I see a bit of myself in Melrose. I can tell that we have a few things in common. She is definitely the type of woman that I would aspire to, and that is why I really wanted her to win. I wanted my values to be approved of by the so-called fashion...
[+] Read Full Review
I see a bit of myself in Melrose. I can tell that we have a few things in common. She is definitely the type of woman that I would aspire to, and that is why I really wanted her to win. I wanted my values to be approved of by the so-called fashion and model icons in North America. Among all contestants, Melrose is the only one that has class. She moves with grace, speaks with great confidence, and never shows any vulgar attitude. She does not make out with a random Spanish guy in the house like CariDee did. She does not curse CariDee like how CariDee said "If Melrose wins, I'm just gonna puke!" Melrose is ambitious, gives her best shot at what she does, and aims for nothing but perfection. That is exactly what a role model for women should be! Oh well. The rest of the women in this world can follow CariDee all they want. I have Melrose to look up to.
Posted jan 13, 2007 5:24 am pt
Even though she could be a b**ch, she was very talented, and deserved to be in the top two. Even though every one else in the house hated her, I really liked her. She actually wasn't that bad, like in the challenge where she won all those clothes,...
[+] Read Full Review
Even though she could be a b**ch, she was very talented, and deserved to be in the top two. Even though every one else in the house hated her, I really liked her. She actually wasn't that bad, like in the challenge where she won all those clothes, they edited it so it looked like she kept it all for herself, but she actually gave all the other people in that challenge part what they wanted. And I know that cuz she said it in an interview, and so did the other people. She was my second favourite to CariDee, so I would have been happy either way, but I think it was better that she came in 2nd, but she was great!
Posted jan 3, 2007 1:58 am pt
I do have to say that it doesn't matter how much of a b*--h everyone thought she was, she was a really good model. I do have to say that most of her pictures were pretty good. I did love her Donald/Melania Trump picutre, she did look like...
[+] Read Full Review
I do have to say that it doesn't matter how much of a b*--h everyone thought she was, she was a really good model. I do have to say that most of her pictures were pretty good. I did love her Donald/Melania Trump picutre, she did look like Melania.
She won so many challenges and got the first call up many times. She did sound like a CoverGirl for her CoverGirl commercial and I could picture that commercial on the air. I think people would have liked her if she wasn't such a b*--ch to everyone around her. Her fakeness was also an issue. I wasn't even there and I could feel the fakeness coming from her.
I still wouldn't have wanted her to win though. I would have wanted CariDee or Brooke. Though... CARIDEE DID WIN! YEAH!
I think if Melrose can just try to be herself more and stop being such a perfectionist, she will probably do alright.
Posted dec 9, 2006 2:26 am pt