All critic scores are converted to a 100-point scale. If a critic does not indicate a score, we assign a score based on the general impression given by the text of the review. Learn more...
Average User Score:




9
(232 sources)
I like Simon as a judge, however his attraction to Paula is distracting to the singers and he act as he is not getting enough attention. He acts like a spoiled boy that wants all the attention. He and Paula should just get a room somewhere before...
[+] Read Full Review
I like Simon as a judge, however his attraction to Paula is distracting to the singers and he act as he is not getting enough attention. He acts like a spoiled boy that wants all the attention. He and Paula should just get a room somewhere before the show so they can keep their hands off each other. He is not respectful to Paula regardless is she makes any sence or not. The singers respect his oponion, however his infactuation with Paula is taking the attention away from the artist. Simon acts bored with American Idol and will do anything for attention.
Posted mar 25, 2009 10:23 am pt
One thing I have to admit about Simon Cowell is that he isn't boring or afraid to say what he thinks. I have watched AMerican Idol a few times to realize that Simon's job is to hurt people but also make them famous. To be honest, I don't think...
[+] Read Full Review
One thing I have to admit about Simon Cowell is that he isn't boring or afraid to say what he thinks. I have watched AMerican Idol a few times to realize that Simon's job is to hurt people but also make them famous. To be honest, I don't think that makes sense, but that is just me. I think he is really good with his punch lines and some of his insults are hilarious one-liners. My favorite had to be where he insults a person singing goth music whose is screaming and whining a terrible noise. Simon told him he should sing in a dark room. Thank you.
Posted feb 11, 2009 6:47 am pt
Many people do not like Simon Cowell, saying he is arrogant or too rough on the contestants of American Idol. I think he is just pushing people to be their best. Maybe he goes a bit overboard on the comments at times, but for the most part, I...
[+] Read Full Review
Many people do not like Simon Cowell, saying he is arrogant or too rough on the contestants of American Idol. I think he is just pushing people to be their best. Maybe he goes a bit overboard on the comments at times, but for the most part, I think he wants to see all the singers and contestants do their best. American Idol wouldn't be the same without Simon Cowell. In real life, and when it comes to charity and the like, its obvious he cares about people. Simon Cowell is a pro in the music industry, and respected by many artists.
Posted jul 5, 2008 11:05 am pt
Do not mess with this guy. He scares me sometime. Doesnt he scare you? His face is like always like this -> =.= its seriously scary. But i think he is the most honest judge. but he is seriously weird in a wayy. bUT AS i said a very fair judge. But...
[+] Read Full Review
Do not mess with this guy. He scares me sometime. Doesnt he scare you? His face is like always like this -> =.= its seriously scary. But i think he is the most honest judge. but he is seriously weird in a wayy. bUT AS i said a very fair judge. But Cornie worked her evil ways around him. Okay, jsut kidding. shes an awesome singer. If simon made her cry, i would bash him up so badly he he... okay thinking of something. Anyway, i love him as a judge but sometimes he is so irritating i feel like killing him?
Posted may 13, 2008 8:36 pm pt
simon cowell is the third judge of the hit show american idol. i believe that simon thinks brits are better than americans, which doesnt bother me. he is ussualy the meanest(compered to the always nice paula), but sometimes the most honest judge ....
[+] Read Full Review
simon cowell is the third judge of the hit show american idol. i believe that simon thinks brits are better than americans, which doesnt bother me. he is ussualy the meanest(compered to the always nice paula), but sometimes the most honest judge . his rude comments ussualy make his best friend, ryan seacrest talk back to him but i enjoy it when they have arguments. i also think simon is very funny especcialy when he complains about a contestants performance.(such as, "bloody hell!") he also has discovered many popular artists, such as leona lewis and that pop slash opra band whos name i cant remember. plz visit my profile!
Posted may 10, 2008 2:48 am pt
I've watched American Idol for seven seasons. I have found that Simon is right on with his comments. I think he is a true mentor. Mentors are not and cannot be your friend. They have the hard task of being honest. A mentor is someone who pushes...
[+] Read Full Review
I've watched American Idol for seven seasons. I have found that Simon is right on with his comments. I think he is a true mentor. Mentors are not and cannot be your friend. They have the hard task of being honest. A mentor is someone who pushes you out of the nest and on to your goal. The goal here is to win the competition. I appreciate a person who is honest with themselves and others. Have you noticed how his comments always refer to winning the competition.
I also think it quite rude to interrupt him and boo him when he is expressing his opinion. I like hearing from all the judges but somehow for the most part when it gets to him he gets the boos. I think it takes a geniunly caring person to be as honest as he is. I wish he wouldn't say, "I'm sorry" after he critic's a performance. He should just give his opinion and not apologize. "It is what it is." I love the show and think it is one of the few shows that motive young people who watch it.
Posted mar 18, 2008 12:24 pm pt
Sometimes he gives you a laughter on the popular reality [i] "American Idol" [/i] but other times he can be [b] kinda [/b] mean. Not all the time though. He is still has a heart and laughter, and chokebox (lol), and Simon Cowell is a good judge....
[+] Read Full Review
Sometimes he gives you a laughter on the popular reality [i] "American Idol" [/i] but other times he can be [b] kinda [/b] mean. Not all the time though. He is still has a heart and laughter, and chokebox (lol), and Simon Cowell is a good judge. It's not like everyone will be picked for American Idol, but that guy in Season 7 sure loved Simon Cowell a lot. And the Japenese (or Chinese, sorry) girl in X-Factor, really had a heart for Simon. And Connie (From Britian's Got Talent) also had a heart. People still do care about Simon. - ThereGoesHalo3.
Posted jan 19, 2008 11:58 pm pt
Never have I seen someone that just captivated me on televison like Simon Cowell did on Amerian Idol! What a Man!! His comments is what really gets to you....doesnt it?? He is someone that just speaks his mind with no intention of holding back...
[+] Read Full Review
Never have I seen someone that just captivated me on televison like Simon Cowell did on Amerian Idol! What a Man!! His comments is what really gets to you....doesnt it?? He is someone that just speaks his mind with no intention of holding back anything! If you ever wanted an honest opinion from anyone, Simon is the one to surely give it to you!!! He is a smart dresser and today is one of the most celebrated celebrities in the world... people just love him!! Isnt that shocking! He can be brutal and at times be nice... But, what a man!!!
Posted sep 22, 2007 7:28 pm pt
I believe that God uses him as an instrument to either open or close the door to people who are chasing a dream. If I ever dared perform in front of him and he said, "yes" Then, it's like God saying yes. Because it's a miracle. He's on our...
[+] Read Full Review
I believe that God uses him as an instrument to either open or close the door to people who are chasing a dream. If I ever dared perform in front of him and he said, "yes" Then, it's like God saying yes. Because it's a miracle. He's on our families top prayer list just like Bianca Ryan. We always pray for their safety. I know I'll never meet any of them but by spirit I feel them always in my heart. I wonder if he has wife or kids. www. my space.com/ julissa luvsalex or www. my space/ julissa foss click on my videos. You guys should pray for him too. He's a gift from God. He speaks truth just like Jesus did.
Posted aug 22, 2007 1:40 pm pt
I love Simon, he is so funny and honest..it cracks me up!! He is one of the three judges on American Idol and man he is just awesome. I LOVE how is so honest..why do people not like him? He is just telling the truth.Overall Simon is cool, really...
[+] Read Full Review
I love Simon, he is so funny and honest..it cracks me up!! He is one of the three judges on American Idol and man he is just awesome. I LOVE how is so honest..why do people not like him? He is just telling the truth.Overall Simon is cool, really good judge....he's wonderful.
Posted jul 13, 2007 6:40 am pt