Critics Scoreboard
All critic scores are converted to a 100-point scale. If a critic does not indicate a score, we assign a score based on the general impression given by the text of the review. Learn more...
Average Critic Score:
70
(31 sources)
70
(31 sources)
-
91
Entertainment Weekly
I mean no impertinence when I say that as a portrait of love and grief, writer-director Mike White's exceptional film Year of the Dog deserves the same admiration accorded Joan Didion's exceptional memoir "The Year of Magical Thinking." Read Full Review » -
91
The Onion (A.V. Club)
White's gently perceptive film is a funny, poignant, emotionally honest minor-key character study. Read Full Review » -
89
Austin Chronicle
Dern is hilarious as the obsessive sister-in-law, Sarsgaard plays oddball dog-man to perfection, Pais is perfectly awkward as Peggy's nervous boss, Reilly rocks the subtle humor of Peggy's hunting-obsessed neighbor, and Shannon gives a breakout performance. Read Full Review » -
88
Charlotte Observer
Until Year of the Dog, I've never seen a movie where someone obsessed over a puppy. Read Full Review » -
88
TV Guide
It may sound as if first-time director White is having his fun at the expense of introverted, asocial people who prefer the company of cats and dogs and gravitate toward animal-rights activism because the very idea of dealing with human problems requires an empathy they can't muster. But empathy is exactly what makes the film work. Read Full Review » -
75
New York Daily News
While some may be put off by Peggy's wild-eyed mania, and the film's broadly comic tone, Shannon makes this lost spirit strikingly sympathetic. Read Full Review » -
75
Premiere
Year of the Dog would have benefited from a stronger hand behind the camera (White's general aesthetic basically involves cribbing heavily from Wes Anderson and Jared Hess), but as a showcase for Shannon, it ends up being strangely moving. Read Full Review » -
75
New York Post
Shannon is wonderful as a woman pushed over the edge by the death of her pet in Year of the Dog, a very low-key, well-acted dramedy. Read Full Review » -
75
Chicago Tribune
In Year of the Dog, there are dark moments that are both strangely poignant and bizarrely hilarious. The ending took me by surprise. In a way it's a cheat, a redemption that arrives out of nowhere. But it's also a cosmic joke, a perfectly funny, sincere salute to dog and pet-lovers everywhere. Read Full Review » -
75
Christian Science Monitor
The conceit of the movie is that everyone is obsessed by something and never really tunes into anybody else. Read Full Review » -
75
Portland Oregonian
A rough little comedy of tone. White, making his directorial debut, asks if the search for self is still heroic when the discoveries are unpleasant. Read Full Review » -
75
San Francisco Chronicle
One of those quirky little movies that you marvel ever got made. Read Full Review » -
75
USA Today
An engaging tragicomedy, exploring the consequences of single-minded fervor in a humorous and humane fashion. Read Full Review » -
70
Chicago Reader
Despite the gimmicky direction and a disappointing climax, this is a distinctive and unsettling comedy. Read Full Review » -
70
The New York Times
It's funny ha-ha but firmly in touch with its downer side, which means it's also funny in a kind of existential way. Read Full Review » -
70
Los Angeles Times
With pathos competing equally against the often pungent laughs for the audience's attention, it's a movie that is both unsettling and amusing, most comparable to "Chuck & Buck" in tone. Read Full Review » -
70
LA Weekly
So oppressive is Peggy's world -- Year of the Dog is the best evocation I've seen of how much worse it is to be depressed in a sunny climate -- that when she finally loses control, it feels more like catharsis than madness. Read Full Review » -
70
Salon.com
Year of the Dog is an enjoyable, patchy, rambling affair, a series of bittersweet comic sketches strung together with thin wire. Read Full Review » -
70
The Hollywood Reporter
Overall, Year of the Dog evinces an appealing sentimentality without being maudlin or only puppy-dog cute. Read Full Review » -
70
Variety
A satisfying and funny, if ironic, comedy intended for lovers of both the beast and/or sophisticated laughs. Read Full Review » -
70
-
70
-
67
Baltimore Sun
White throws in a dog-in-peril shot to ensure the audience's sympathies. The ploy works, perhaps too well, turning Year of the Dog less into the askew character study it wants to be than a showcase of lovable-dog shots. Read Full Review » -
63
The Globe and Mail (Toronto)
The ironic, cheery-bland tone, the two-dimensional characters and episodic structure, say "comedy," while the events in the script say "bipolar depression." Read Full Review » -
63
Boston Globe
Shannon gives the movie its inner life. Maybe the movie will give her back her comedy career. Read Full Review » -
63
-
60
The New Yorker
The movie's meaning seems to be: we're all crippled in some way, so just live with it--celebrate it, even. That isn't satire; it's moss-brained sentiment that turns "sensitivity" into a dimly dejected view of life. Read Full Review » -
60
Village Voice
Mike White, writer of "Chuck & Buck" and "The School of Rock" (and oddball actor in both), here directs his latest geek's revenge fantasy like a psychotherapeutically treated Todd Solondz. Read Full Review » -
58
Seattle Post-Intelligencer
The curious character study is a comedy in a minor key, but for all White's fascination with Peggy, he brings little conviction to the healing message under all this creepiness and social awkwardness, beyond what Shannon brings to the role. Read Full Review » -
40
Film Threat
Billed as a comedy but it would be every bit as accurate to categorize it as science fiction or a World War II drama. It is simply not a funny film. Read Full Review » -
38
Miami Herald
In Year of the Dog, director Mike White willfully violates one of the great unwritten rules of Hollywood screenwriting: Kill as many human characters as you want, just spare the dog. Read Full Review »
You Say
click on a star to rate
